Readers have been pressing for a solution to the financial crisis. But first
it is necessary to understand the problem.
Here is the problem as I see it. If my diagnosis is correct,
the solution below might be appropriate.
Let�s begin with the fact that the financial crisis is more
or less worldwide. The mechanism that spread the American-made financial crisis
abroad was the massive US
trade deficit. Every year the countries with which the US has trade
deficits end up in the aggregate with hundreds of billions of dollars.
Countries don�t put these dollars in a mattress. They invest
them. They buy up US companies, real estate, and toll roads. They also purchase
US financial assets. They finance the US government budget deficit by
purchasing Treasury bonds and bills. They help to finance the US mortgage
market by purchasing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac bonds. They buy financial
instruments, such as mortgage-backed
securities and other derivatives, from US investment banks, and that is how
the US financial crisis was spread abroad. If the US current account was close
to balance, the contagion would have lacked a mechanism by which to spread.
One reason the US trade deficit is so large is the practice
of US corporations offshoring
their production of goods and services for US markets. When these products
are brought into the US to be sold, they count as imports.
Thus, economists were wrong to see the trade deficit as a
non-problem and to regard offshoring as a plus for the US economy.
The fact that much of the financial world is polluted with
US toxic financial instruments could affect the ability of the US Treasury to
borrow the money to finance the bailout of the financial institutions. Foreign
central banks might need their reserves to bail out their own financial
systems. As the US savings rate is approximately zero, the only alternative to
foreign borrowing is the printing of money.
Financial deregulation was an important factor in the
development of the crisis. The most reckless deregulation occurred in 1999,
2000, and 2004. (See The
Bailout Will Fail, October 07, .) 2008Lax mortgage lending policies
grew out of pressures placed on mortgage lenders during the
1990s by the US Department of Justice and federal regulatory agencies torace-norm
their mortgage lending and to provide below-market loans to preferred
minorities. Subprime mortgages became a potential systemic threat when issuers
ceased to bear any risk by selling the mortgages, which were then amalgamated
with other mortgages and became collateral for mortgage-backed securities.
Federal Reserve chairman Alan Greenspan�s inexplicable low
interest rate policy allowed the systemic threat to develop. Low interest rates
push up housing prices by lowering monthly mortgage payments, thus increasing
housing demand. Rising home prices created equity to justify 100 percent
mortgages. Buyers leveraged themselves to the hilt and lacked the ability to
make payments when they lost their jobs or when adjustable rates and interest
escalator clauses pushed up monthly payments.
Wall Street analysts pushed financial institutions to
increase their earnings, which they did by leveraging their assets and by
insuring debt instruments instead of maintaining appropriate reserves. This
spread the crisis from banks to insurance companies.
Finance chiefs around the world are dealing with the crisis
by bailing out banks and by lowering interest rates. This suggests that the
authorities see the problem as a solvency problem for the financial
institutions and as a liquidity problem. US Treasury Secretary Paulson�s
solution, for example, leaves unattended the continuing mortgage defaults and
foreclosures. The fall in the US stock market predicts a serious recession,
which means rising unemployment and more defaults and foreclosures.
In place of a liquidity problem, I see an over-abundance of
debt instruments relative to wealth. A fractional reserve banking system based
on fiat money appears to be capable of creating debt instruments faster than an
economy can create real wealth. Add in credit card debt, stocks purchased on
margin, and leveraged derivatives, and debt is pyramided relative to real
assets.
Add in the mark-to-market rule,
which forces troubled assets to be undervalued, thus threatening the solvency
of institutions, and short-selling, which drives down the shares of troubled
institutions, thereby depriving them of credit lines, and you have an outline
of the many causes of the current crisis.
If the diagnosis is correct, the solution is multifaceted.
Instead of wasting $700 billion on a bailout of the guilty
that does not address the problem, the money should be used to refinance the
troubled mortgages, as was done during the Great Depression. If the mortgages
were not defaulting, the income flows from the mortgage interest through to the
holders of the mortgage-backed securities would be restored. Thus, the solvency
problem faced by the holders of these securities would be at an end.
The financial markets must be carefully reregulated, not
overregulated or wrongly regulated.
To shore up the credibility of the US Treasury�s own credit
rating and the US dollar as world reserve currency, the US budget and trade
deficits must be addressed. The US budget deficit can be eliminated by halting
the Bush Regime�s gratuitous wars and by cutting the extravagant US military
budget. The US spends more on military than the rest of the world combined.
This is insane and unaffordable. A balanced budget is a signal to the world
that the US government is serious and is taking measures to reduce its demand
on the supply of world savings.
The trade deficit is more difficult to reduce as the US has
stupidly permitted itself to become dependent not merely on imports of foreign
energy, but also on imports of foreign manufactured goods, including advanced
technology products. Steps can be taken to bring home the offshored production
of US goods for US markets. This would substantially reduce the trade deficit
and, thus, restore credibility to the US dollar as world reserve currency.
Follow-up measures would be required to insure that US imports do not greatly
exceed exports.
The US will have to set aside the racial privileges that
federal bureaucrats pulled out of the Civil Rights Act and restore sound
lending practices. If the US government itself wishes to subsidize at taxpayer
expense home purchases by non-qualified buyers, that is a political decision
subject to electoral ratification. But the US government must cease to force
private lenders to breech the standards of prudence.
The issuance of credit cards must be brought back to prudent
standards, with checks on credit history, employment, and income. Balances that
grow over time must be seen as a problem against which reserves must be
provided, instead of a source of rising interest income to the credit card
companies.
Fractional reserve banking must be reined in by higher
reserve requirements, rising over time perhaps to 100 percent. If banks were
true financial intermediaries, they would not have money creating power, and
the proliferation of debt relative to wealth would be reduced.
Does the US have the leadership to realize the problem and
to deal with it?
Not if Bush, Cheney, Paulson, Bernanke, McCain and Obama are
the best leadership that America can produce.
The Great Depression lasted a decade because the authorities
were unable to comprehend that the Federal Reserve had allowed the supply of
money to shrink. The shrunken money supply could not employ the same number of
workers at the same wages, and it could not purchase the same amount of goods
and service at the same prices. Thus, prices and employment fell.
The
explanation of the Great Depression was not known until the 1960s when
Milton Friedman and Anna Schwartz published their Monetary
History of the United States.
Given the stupidity of our leadership and the stupidity of
so many of our economists, we may learn what happened to us this year in 2038,
three decades from now.
Paul
Craig Roberts [email
him] was Assistant Secretary of the Treasury during President
Reagan�s first term. He was Associate Editor of the Wall Street Journal. He has
held numerous academic appointments, including the William E. Simon Chair,
Center for Strategic and International Studies, Georgetown University,
and Senior Research Fellow, Hoover Institution, Stanford University. He was
awarded the Legion of Honor by French President Francois Mitterrand. He is the
author of Supply-Side
Revolution : An Insider�s Account of Policymaking in Washington; Alienation
and the Soviet Economy and Meltdown:
Inside the Soviet Economy, and is the co-author with Lawrence M.
Stratton of The
Tyranny of Good Intentions : How Prosecutors and Bureaucrats Are Trampling the
Constitution in the Name of Justice. Click here for
Peter Brimelow�s Forbes Magazine interview with Roberts about the recent
epidemic of prosecutorial misconduct.