Israel�s daily newspaper Yedioth Ahronoth published a
poll Thursday showing the Likud, headed by former Prime Minister Binyamin
Netanyahu, with 32 seats (out of a total of 120) and the currently ruling
Kadima party taking 26 seats. The once all-power Labor party polled a mere 8
seats.
More interesting than these numbers, however, is the
assertion in another poll conducted by the War and Peace Index that found a
plurality of Israelis questioned believed the chances of peace were best with
Netanyahu back at the helm.
Netanyahu for peace? That�s like Klan members for Obama.
What�s going on in the Israeli collective mind?
Lest we think the Israelis are no longer interested in
peace, the same poll that found Netanyahu most likely to bring peace found a
majority of Israeli Jews still support the idea of a Palestinian state and a
two-state solution generally. Meanwhile, the Likud Party platform clearly
states that it will refuse to recognize a Palestinian state and that,
furthermore, only autonomy would be afforded the Palestinians by them. This is
clearly a recipe for further disaster. So what is driving this push for
Netanyahu?
Part of it is happening here, not surprisingly. Last week,
U.S. Rep. Robert Wexler of Florida, a Democrat, claimed that President-elect
Obama would have a good working relationship with Netanyahu. Given the record
that Netanyahu had of �working� with President Clinton (Clinton got two very
small agreements out of Netanyahu only after much disagreement between the two
men), it�s highly doubtful that an Obama-Netanyahu relationship will be better
� though it�s fun to say out loud.
The other factors driving Netanyahu�s numbers are the return
to the Likud of several prominent members, notably Dan Meridor and Ze�ev
(Benny) Begin, son of the former Prime Minister. Meridor was finance minister
under Netanyahu until 1997 and then had joined the short-lived Centre Party
formed from Likud and Labor members to find a �happy medium� between Netanyahu
and then leader of the opposition Ehud Barak. Meridor�s inclusion on the Likud
list gives the impression, as do Wexler�s remarks, that the Likud is centrist
and moderate.
However, the inclusion of Begin on the list points to the
real truth. Begin was a Likud member from 1988 to 1997, when he left the Likud
to form the Herut party that is currently headed by Michael Kleiner, a champion
of the continued practice of settlement in the Palestinian Territories and an
opponent to any accommodation with the Palestinians. Begin shares those points
of view (he left the Likud over Netanyahu agreeing to evacuate the IDF from
Hebron).
Netanyahu�s courting of Begin is proof of where Netanyahu
truly stands. So how can he be stopped before the elections on February 10?
Netanyahu�s 32 seats would be augmented by nine seats from the far-right
Yisrael Beiteinu party and six from the even further right-wing Jewish Home
party, giving him 47 seats. With the religious parties (Shas has 11 seats and
United Torah Judaism has seven seats), he would have a 61-seat majority with
four seats to spare. But he would have to make broad concessions to Shas, which
always demands special considerations for its pet issues (religious education,
greater enforcement of Jewish law, etc.). Such a majority would likely be
short-lived, but it could do great damage in the meantime.
The strongest challenger to Netanyahu is current acting
Prime Minister Tzipi Livni of Kadima. As noted, she has 26 seats in the latest
polls. Giving her Labor�s eightseats, Meretz�s seven seats (Meretz are the
social democrats), and the burgeoning Green Party�s three seats, she would have
44 seats, three fewer than Netanyahu would have before needing to approach the
religious parties.
Livni failed to form a government in the fall by failing to
successfully court Shas. And, in the minds of the Israeli left, Shas is best
left out of any government because of its unreasonable demands. So to whom
could Livni go to best Netanyahu?
The first choice for her would be United Torah Judaism, with
their seven seats. And, while UTJ does have demands that are similar to Shas,
the parties that make it up have traditionally supported most governments since
their philosophy is best described as �non-Zionist.� Promise that the IDF won�t
draft their yeshiva bochers, and Livni�s got 51 seats. She still needs 10 more
seats for a majority.
The Arab parties would give her the edge. They have 11 seats
in this poll, giving her 62 seats. Before the 1967 war, Arab parties were
routinely part of governments, either officially or on a non-official basis.
The key point for Livni to consider is this: By approaching the Arabs for their
support, she has absolutely nothing to lose. Perhaps some racist members of
Labor and Kadima would protest the move, but these same people would be looking
to keep their current government jobs.
Israeli Arabs were the key voters in the 1999 election of
Ehud Barak as prime minister, turning out in record numbers to cast a ballot
for the man they believed would finally bring them equality and justice for
their brothers in the Territories. That he failed to fulfill his promises to
them caused them to cast blank ballots in the 2001 election against Ariel
Sharon. Give the Israeli Arabs a sense of a real voice, and they will vote. And
they�re not going to vote for Netanyahu, quite obviously.
So you want to keep the peace process going, Ms. Livni? It�s
the Arabs, stupid.
Andrew
E. Mathis is a medical editor, Holocaust historian, and adjunct professor of
English and humanities at Villanova University.