"It's . . . poetic justice, in
that the people that brewed this toxic Kool-Aid found themselves drinking a lot
of it in the end." --Warren Buffett, American investor
�By a continuing process of inflation, government can confiscate, secretly and
unobserved, an important part of the wealth of their citizens.� --John Maynard
Keynes (1883-1946)
"New money that enters the economy does not affect all economic actors
equally nor does new money influence all economic actors at the same time.
Newly created money must enter into the economy at a specific point. Generally
this monetary injection comes via credit expansion through the banking sector.
Those who receive this new money first benefit at the expense of those who
receive the money only after it has snaked through the economy and prices have
had a chance to adjust." --Friedrich A. Hayek
(1899-1992), Austrian economist
When Fed
Chairman Ben
Bernanke says the economic situation is
worsening, you'd better believe him. In fact, the U.S. credit markets are
collapsing under our very eyes, and there is no end in sight as to when this
will stop, let alone reverse itself.
- Leading
economic indicators for the U.S. economy are falling.
- Consumer
confidence sentiment is falling as mortgage equity
withdrawals are drying up.
- Employment
numbers are falling.
- The January 2008 report on the U.S.
service economy indicates that it contracted early in
the year for the first time in 58 months.
- The
number of new jobless claims is
still dangerously high.
- The
housing
crisis is getting up steam; banks have to place larger
and larger subprime losses on their balance sheets, thus undermining their
capital bases and bringing many of them to the brink of insolvency.
- The
credit-ratings
agencies are under siege.
- Bond
guarantee insurance companies are in the process of loosing their triple-A
ratings and some are on the brink of bankruptcy.
- The
$2.6 trillion municipal
bond market is about to take a nosedive, if and when the
bond insurers do not pull it through.
- The
leveraged corporate loan market is in disarray.
- The
more than a trillion dollar market for mortgage-
and debt-backed securities could collapse completely if
the largest American mortgage insurers continue to suffer crippling
losses.
- Large
hedge funds
are losing money on a high scale and they are suffering from a run on
their assets.
- In
the U.S., total debt as a
percentage of GDP is at more than 300 percent, a record
level (N.B.: in 1980, it was 125 percent!).
- And, finally, the worldwide hundreds-of- trillion
dollar derivatives
market could implode anytime, if too
many financial institutions go under during the coming months, as most of
these transactions are inter-institution trades.
There
are a few positive straws in the wind, such as the fact that manufacturing output seems to be holding up pretty
well, as the devalued dollar stimulates exports, but the overall economic
picture remains bleak. This is a tribute to the U.S. economy's resiliency.
This
mess all began in the early 2000s, and even as far back as the early 1980s,
when the Fed and the SEC adopted a hands-off approach to financial markets,
guided by the new economic religion that "markets can do no wrong."
What we are witnessing is the failure of nearly 30 years of so-called
conservative debt-ridden and deregulation-ridden economic policies.
It must be understood that the
most recent subprime
problem really began in 2000, when the credit-rating agency of
Standard & Poors issued a pronouncement saying that "piggyback"
mortgage financing of houses, when a second mortgage is taken to pay the
down-payment on a first mortgage, was no more likely to lead to default than
more standard mortgages. This encouraged mortgage lending institutions to relax
their lending practices, going as far as lending on mortgages with no
down-payment whatsoever, and even postponing capital and interest payments for
some time. And, with the Fed and the SEC looking the other way, a fatal next
step was taken. Banks and their subsidiaries decided to follow new toxic and
risky rules of banking.
Indeed, while traditionally banks would borrow short and
lend long, they went one giant step further: they began transforming long-term
loans, such as mortgages, car loans, student loans, etc., into short-term
loans. Indeed, they got into the alchemist business of bundling together
relatively long-term loans into packages that they sliced into smaller credit
instruments that had all the characteristics of short-term commercial paper,
but were carrying higher yields. They then sold these new "structured
investment vehicles" (SIVs), for a fee, to all kinds of
investors who were looking for higher yields than the meager rates that
alternatives were paying. And, since banks were behind these new artificial
financial assets, the credit agencies gave them an AAA rating, which allowed
regulated pension funds and insurance companies to invest in them, believing
they were both safe and liquid. They were in for a shock. When the housing
bubble burst, the value of real assets behind the new financial instruments
began declining, pulling the rug out from beneath the asset-backed
paper market (ABCP), which became illiquid and toxic. With
hardly any trading on the new instruments, nobody knew the true value of the
paper, and thus nobody was willing to buy it. This crisis of confidence has now
permeated to other credit markets and is threatening the entire financial
system as the contagion spreads.
As late as 2003-04, then Fed
Chairman Alan Greenspan was not the least worried by the
subprime-financed-housing-mortgage bubble but was instead encouraging people to
take out adjustable rate mortgages, even though interest rates were at a
30-year low and were bound to increase. Even in late 2006, newly appointed Fed
Chairman Ben Bernanke professed not to be preoccupied by the housing bubble,
saying that high prices were only a reflection of a strong economy. Mind you,
this was more than one year after the housing market peaked in the spring of
2005. History will record that the Fed and the SEC did nothing to prevent the
debt pyramid from reaching the dangerous levels it attained and which is now
crushing the economy.
On a longer span of time, when one
looks at a graph provided by the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA)
which shows the relative
importance of total outstanding debt (corporate, financial,
government, plus personal) in relation to the economy, one is struck by the
fact that this ratio stayed around 1.2 times GDP for decades. Then, something
big happened in the early 1980s, and the ratio started to rise, with only a
slight pause in the mid-1990s, to reach the rarefied level of 3.1 times GDP
presently, nearly 200 percent more than it used to be.
The adoption of massive
tax cuts coupled with government deficit
spending policies, and deregulation policies, by the Reagan and subsequent administrations, all culminating in a
grotesque way under the current administration, contributed massively to this
unprecedented debt
bubble. It took many years to build up the
debt pyramid, and it will take many years to unwind it and to reduce this
cumulative mountain of debt to a more manageable size.
That is the big picture behind
this crisis. It is much bigger than the S&L crisis of the 1980s, which
looks puny in comparison with the current one. That is why I think this crisis
will linger on for at least a few more years, possibly until 2010-11.
Rodrigue Tremblay
lives in Montreal and can be reached at rodrigue.tremblay@yahoo.com.
He is the author of the book �'The New American Empire.� His new book, �The Code for Global Ethics,�
will be published in 2008. Visit his blog site at thenewamericanempire.com/blog