The Department of Justice, in refusing to release Vice
President Dick Cheney�s interview transcript with the special prosecutor who
investigated the leak of covert CIA operative Valerie Plame Wilson, said for
the first time last week that contents of Cheney�s interview have been
classified.
In a letter sent Thursday to Citizens of Responsibility and
Ethics in Washington (CREW), the government watchdog group that filed a Freedom
of Information Act request last month seeking access to the transcript, the
DOJ�s Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) said the documents have been withheld, in
part, because it contains information �protected from disclosure by the
National Security Act.�
�We are withholding the records . . . because they are
protected by the deliberative process, presidential communications, and law
enforcement investigative privileges,� states the Sept. 18 letter sent by OLC
attorney Paul Coborn to CREW chief counsel Anne Weissman. �We are also
withholding them . . . because the records were compiled for law enforcement
purposes and their production �could reasonably be expected to interfere with
enforcement proceedings.� The Department is concerned that releasing the
records could interfere with future Department investigations by discouraging
voluntary cooperation.
�Finally, we are withholding portions of the records . . . because
they are classified and contain information protected from disclosure by the
National Security Act of 1947.�
In a separate development, a federal judge last Saturday
ordered Cheney to preserve all documents during his seven years as vice
president. CREW sued the vice president challenging Cheney�s narrow
interpretation of his obligations under the Presidential Records Act, based in
large part on his claim that he is not part of the executive branch. In
granting CREW�s request for a preliminary injunction, the court rejected the
arguments of the White House that they were preserving all vice presidential
records, which they defined narrowly to include only functions �specially
assigned� to the vice president by the president and his duties as president of
the Senate.
Henry Waxman, the Democratic chairman of the he House
Oversight and Government Reform Committee, subpoenaed Attorney General Michael
Mukasey in June for Cheney�s interview transcript as well a copy the transcript
of President George W. Bush�s interview with Special Prosecutor Patrick
Fitzgerald, and the grand jury testimony of Karl Rove, Bush�s former top aide.
But Mukasey did not state that the either of the transcripts
contained classified information when he refused to comply with Waxman�s
subpoena. Mukasey advised Bush to assert his executive privilege powers to
block release of the transcripts.
�I am greatly concerned about the chilling effect that
compliance with the [House Oversight] Committee�s subpoena would have on future
White House deliberations and White House cooperation with future Justice
Department investigations,� Mukasey wrote in a letter to Bush on July 16.
Yet Patrick Fitzgerald, the special prosecutor who spent
three years investigating White House officials� role in the Plame leak, said
in a letter sent to Waxman in July that the interviews he conducted with Bush
and Cheney in 2004 were not protected by grand jury secrecy rules and could
arguably be turned over to Congress if authorized by the Justice Department.
Moreover, Fitzgerald said that in his capacity as special
counsel he did not enter into a pre-arranged agreement with the White House to
keep secret Bush and Cheney�s interview transcripts.
�I can advise you that as to any interviews of either the
President or Vice President not protected by the rules of grand jury secrecy,
there were no agreements, conditions and understandings between the Office of
Special Counsel or the Federal Bureau of Investigation� and either the
president or vice president �regarding the conduct and use of the interview or
interviews,� Fitzgerald�s July 3 letter addressed to Waxman says.
Fitzgerald has turned over to Waxman�s committee �FBI 302
reports� of interviews with CIA and State Department officials and other
individuals involved in the CIA leak, Waxman said in a letter to Mukasey last
December.
But �the White House has been blocking Mr. Fitzgerald from
providing key documents to the Committee,� including transcripts of
Fitzgerald�s interviews with Bush and Cheney, Waxman said.
Two senior DOJ officials knowledgeable about the CIA leak
investigation said Saturday that officials in the Office of the Vice President
issued a request to the DOJ recently to classify Cheney�s transcript. However,
the DOJ officials did not know the exact timing of when the DOJ classified portions
of the transcript. A DOJ spokesman did not return calls for comment Saturday.
House Judiciary Committee Chairman John Conyers has also
been actively pursuing the interview transcripts. In June, he issued a subpoena
to Mukasey for a wide range of documents related to Fitzgerald�s probe and was
also rejected.
Conyers and Waxman�s interest in the CIA leak case was
revived with the publication in June of former White House press secretary
McClellan�s memoir which suggested Bush and Cheney played a larger role in the
matter than they have admitted publicly.
Conyers was set to hold a vote Sept. 10 on a contempt
citation for Mukasey for refusing to turn over the subpoenaed documents to his
panel, but decided to �defer� the matter when the DOJ reluctantly released
681-pages of documents related to a voter identification law implemented last
year in the state of Georgia that the Michigan Democrat had sought.
But in a letter sent to Conyers Sept. 9, Keith Nelson, a
deputy attorney general, did not say that Cheney�s interview transcript was
classified. Nelson said he could not release the document because Bush had
already asserted executive privilege.
Senior Bush administration officials disclosed Valerie Plame
Wilson�s identity to several journalists in June and July of 2003 amid White
House efforts to discredit her husband, former U.S. Ambassador Joseph Wilson,
for challenging Bush�s use of bogus intelligence to justify invading Iraq.
Valerie Plame Wilson�s CIA employment was revealed in a July
14, 2003, article by right-wing columnist Robert Novak, effectively destroying
her career. Two months later, a CIA complaint to the Justice Department sparked
a criminal probe into the identity of the leakers.
Initially, Bush professed not to know anything about the matter,
and several of his senior aides, including political adviser Karl Rove and the
vice president�s chief of staff I. Lewis Libby, followed suit.
However, it later became clear that Rove and Libby had a
hand in the Plame leak and that Bush and Cheney had helped organize a campaign
to disparage Wilson by giving critical information to friendly journalists.
On June 24, 2004, Fitzgerald interviewed Bush for 70 minutes
about the Plame leak. The only other member of the Bush team in the room during
the meeting was Jim Sharp, the private lawyer that Bush hired, according to a
press briefing by then-press secretary Scott McClellan.
Fitzgerald had interviewed Cheney several weeks earlier.
According to sources knowledgeable about the vice
president�s testimony, Cheney was specifically asked about conversations he had
with senior aides, including Libby, and queried about whether he was aware of a
campaign led by White House officials to leak Plame�s identity.
It is unknown how Cheney responded to those questions.
Cheney retained a private attorney, Terrence O�Donnell.
At the time of Waxman�s comments, Fitzgerald�s criminal
investigation was still underway, leading to Libby�s indictment in October 2005
and his subsequent conviction in March 2007 on four counts of perjury and
obstruction of justice.
During closing arguments at Libby�s trial, Cheney was
implicated in the leak, as Fitzgerald acknowledged that Cheney was intimately
involved in the scandal and may have told Libby to leak Plame�s status to the
media.
Fitzgerald told jurors that his investigation into the true
nature of the vice president�s involvement was impeded because Libby obstructed
justice.
Libby�s attorney, Theodore Wells, told jurors during his
closing arguments that Fitzgerald had been trying to build a case of conspiracy
against the vice president and Libby and that the prosecution believed Libby
may have lied to federal investigators and to a grand jury to protect Cheney.
�Now, I think the government, through its questions, really
tried to put a cloud over Vice President Cheney,� Wells said.
Rebutting Wells, Fitzgerald told jurors, �You know what?
[Wells] said something here that we�re trying to put a cloud on the vice
president. We�ll talk straight. There is a cloud over the vice president. He
sent Libby off to [meet with New York Times reporter] Judith Miller at the St.
Regis Hotel. At that meeting -- the two-hour meeting -- the defendant talked
about the wife [Plame]. We didn�t put that cloud there. That cloud remains
because the defendant obstructed justice and lied about what happened.�
Jason
Leopold is the author of �News Junkie,� a memoir. Visit
www.newsjunkiebook.com
for a preview. His new website is The
Public Record.