During the time that Bill Clinton was rocking the Democratic
convention, ABC, CBS, and Fox were showing re-runs, NBC was showing the second
hour of �America�s Got Talent,� and the CW was showing the second season finale
of �Pussycat Dolls Present: Girlicious.�
Fewer than two decades ago, the networks gave the
conventions gavel-to-gavel coverage. This year, the networks are giving only
four hours prime time coverage to each convention.
The first televised conventions were in Philadelphia in
1948. At the time, only about 170,000 of the nation�s 42.2 million households
had televisions. The networks, desperate to fill their government-issued
airwaves, begged the nation to believe that television was at the cutting edge
of the future. TV needed politicians; politicians weren�t so sure they needed
TV. By 1960, more than 46 million of the nation�s 58 million households had at
least one TV set, and most stations were broadcasting at least 16 hours a day.
If anyone doubted the potential and power of television, it was quashed that
year during the televised Nixon�Kennedy debates which gave the Massachusetts
senator a lead he never lost. Eight years later, the cameras recorded the
Chicago riots, giving credibility to the antiwar movement and virtually
destroying the Democrats� chance to defeat Richard Nixon, even though the
liberal Hubert Humphrey deplored the police response and Mayor Richard Daley�s
iron fist tactics.
Once, the parties� nominees for president were usually
determined at the convention itself, not months earlier in the media-enhanced
primary campaigns. On the floor of the convention, we at home, watching on
17-inch TV sets, looked forward to the roll call, as each state�s chairman
stood up, usually dressed in something red-white-and-outrageous, and declared
for all America to hear, something to the effect: �Mr. Chairman, the great and
glorious state of Globule Gulch, home of more than 50 hotdog stands per square
mile and the most beautiful women on earth, the place where George Washington
once slept and where cows peacefully graze on our healthy grass, proudly casts
it 85 votes for its favorite son, Governor Lushpuppy Billings.�
By the late 1980s, TV demanded more and more, and the party
leaders began to stage prime time shows to play to TV�s prime�time necessities.
Gone are the spontaneous floor events where delegates march,
laugh, maybe argue with each other, and actually participate in helping shape
the direction of their party, even when the nominee was an incumbent president.
Does anyone hear about the party�s platform and its planks now? Does anyone
even care? The signs on the convention floor are cookie-cutter conformity. The
delegates are nothing more than props. Their role is to go to the myriad
lobbyist-prepared parties, have fun, and act as extras for the show unfolding
before them, and then go home and rally the grassroots support.
Last week, Barack Obama and his campaign staff controlled
every aspect of the convention, including who would be the speakers, what and
how they would say it, when each would appear and for how long. Only President
Clinton�s speech wasn�t vetted. It won�t be any different this week with the
Republicans, but the Republicans may have to check President Bush�s speech
ahead of time, lest it become more comedic than planned.
It was the television media that created the atmosphere that
demanded �interesting visuals� and the seven-second sound bite; and now the
media are upset that politicians, in their infomercial packaged conventions
that play to the camera, have nothing to say. The networks, which created the
monster, are crying there isn�t any news -- and they cut away from what is
interesting, such as the speech by President Clinton -- and turn the cameras
onto themselves. The pontificating pundits with their semi-erudite commentaries
and all-knowing blather that bores viewers more than any politician�s 20-minute
speech, now dominate the prime time coverage and pretend what they�re saying
actually matters. It�s hard to believe that 16,000 members of the media
credentialed to cover each convention couldn�t find any news.
But, there is news. There are stories. The
networks, sitting on their plush assets, have failed to dig out these stories
to better help Americans understand the issues that affect them. And so the
celebrity-driven media spent more time percolating the story of the division
between the Hillary and Obama forces than trying to help Americans better
understand the issues. If the mainstream media were to leave their
color-coordinated broadcast booths and hospitality suites, as the alternative
media have done, and dig beneath the puffery and pageantry, they may find the
greater social and political issues that need to be reported, as well as the
delightful �slice of life� stories that help us better understand our own
lives.
The first TV conventions were the best of the emerging
Reality TV programming before the medium sunk into who would eat what
disgusting insect. America needs both the conventions and the media to be more
real.
Walter
Brasch is professor of journalism at Bloomsburg University and president of the
Pennsylvania Press Club. He is senior author of the critically-acclaimed �The
Press and the State,� and author of ��Unacceptable�: The Federal Response to
Hurricane Katrina� (January 2006) and �Sinking the Ship of State: The
Presidency of George W. Bush� (November 2007), available through amazon.com. You
may contact Brasch at brasch@bloomu.edu
or through his website at: www.walterbrasch.com.