It is
always good to know as a citizen that your leaders think everything is under
control, for this reason I can only begin to imagine the relief people in the
United States must feel when President Bush publicly acknowledges; "I
believe that our economy has got the fundamentals in place.�
I must
admit however that I struggle to understand where the president is getting his
data from and I dread to think what things will look like by the time he admits
that �fundamentals� are not really �in place." According to Alan Greenspan
�as of right now, U.S. economic growth is at zero," �home prices will
continue to weaken� and a boom in oil prices is going to "go on forever."
As he puts it, the US is �clearly on the edge.�
I remember
the time when General Motors Corp. was considered a pillar of the American
dream, a fundamental of the economic miracle. Now, after reporting a quarterly
loss of $722 million, compared with a profit of $950 million a year earlier,
and offering buyouts to 74,000 of its United Auto Workers employees, GM is
clearly not a part of the sound fundamentals which President Bush likes to
describe. The same seems apparent with MGIC Investment Corp., the largest U.S.
mortgage insurer, which posted a record quarterly loss of $1.47 billion and is
also being kept out of the �presidential fundamentals equation.�
Things are
so bad in the United States that during the Senate Banking Committee hearing,
Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson resorted to aliens from outer space to
describe how things are looking; "If someone came down -- a man came down
from Mars -- and you were trying to explain the regulatory structure . . . it's
a patchwork quilt, in many ways." I don�t blame him for looking for such
far fetched metaphors when many economists and banking industry experts,
according to Time magazine, �believe the subprime crisis could metamorphose
into the biggest debacle to hit the sector since the Savings & Loan catastrophe
of the 1980s, which caused some $500 billion in losses to the banking
industry." As Merrill Lynch economist Kathy Bostjancic elaborates �the
impact here could be far larger [than the S&L crisis] in terms of the
dollar amount and the spillover effects into other parts of the economy,
particularly the consumer."
Doug
Duncan, chief economist with the Mortgage Bankers Association, in his updated
2008 forecast says "the principal concern of the current credit crisis
lies in the possibility that banks will eventually run out of capital," as
Dean Baker, co-director of the Centre for Economic and Policy Research, a
Washington think tank, adds, "the amount of debt that's likely to go bad
is virtually certain to be in the high hundreds of billions of dollars, and it
wouldn't surprise me if it ends up crossing a trillion."
In short,
what we have here is the worst housing slump in a quarter century, an economy
which in January alone lost 17,000 jobs, and The Standard & Poor's 500
Index which has fallen three consecutive months, the longest losing streak
since 2003. We also have Americans whose December monthly expenditure on debt
service, housing, medical costs, and food and energy bills has risen to an
unprecedented 66.9 percent of their total spending, the highest since records
began in 1980. According to Ron Blackwell, chief economist at the AFL-CIO,
"American workers are suffering a generation-long decline in living
standards and rising economic insecurity." To add to this, the four-week
moving average of new claims for unemployment benefits is at the highest level
since October 2005, and the University of Michigan�s consumer sentiment index
is marking its lowest point since February 1992 when the economy was emerging
from a recession.
I would
like to know what the president�s fundamentals are. The White House seems to be
isolated from reality. Data provided by the Mortgage Insurance Companies of
America trade group clearly states that U.S. foreclosure rates have risen to
their highest since at least World War II, and defaults on privately insured
U.S. mortgages have risen 37 percent in December from the same month a year
earlier. RealtyTrac Inc. is reporting that foreclosure rates have risen 75
percent in 2007, and the number of homes that have been repossessed, or taken
back by the bank jumped 50 percent nationwide last year. According to The
National Association of Realtors Pending Home Sales Index, pending sales of
previously owned homes have fallen a steeper-than-expected 1.5 percent in
December, and prices of existing U.S. single-family homes dropped 8.9 percent
in the fourth quarter versus a year earlier, the largest decline in the 20-year
history of a national home price index. The National Association of Realtors
has also reported that sales by homeowners have fallen in January to their
lowest reading since the group began reporting annual sales pace in 1999,
something which Northern Trust chief economist Paul Kasriel describes as �more
doom and gloom."
To add to
this, home prices continued their plunge during the last three months of 2007,
setting a real estate trade group's record for the biggest-ever quarterly drop,
the steepest ever recorded by the National Association of Realtors (NAR), which
has been compiling the report since 1979. A Merrill Lynch report in January
forecasted price declines of 15 percent in 2008 and another 10 percent in 2009
before markets begin to recover. On top of this, mortgage applications volume
tumbled 22.6 percent during the week ending Feb. 15, according to the Mortgage Bankers
Association's weekly application survey, while
Standard
& Poor's Ratings Services said its rating outlook on US homebuilders
remains emphatically negative and it believes a recovery is not yet in sight,
as six of the nation's largest mortgage lenders have temporarily stopped
foreclosure proceedings, in a joint effort to cool the raging foreclosure
crisis through a project known as Project Lifeline.
Things are
so bad in the housing sector, a sector which one would deem as part of the
fundamentals of a sound economy, that in a conference call with analysts,
Kenneth Lewis, the chief executive of Bank of America, pointed out that more
borrowers appear to be giving up on their homes as prices fall, noting a
"change in social attitudes toward default." Not surprising
considering that CIBC World Markets forecast U.S. house prices will end up
sliding 20 percent before the market stabilizes, and estimates 50 percent of
U.S. homeowners who took out subprime mortgages in 2006 will end up owing more
than their house is worth. As Michael Englund, chief economist at Action
Economics put it, �there seems to be a sense of a very deep-seated collapse in
the economy.�
The
Philadelphia Federal Reserve's index of manufacturing activity in the U.S.
Northeast also indicated the same disparity between Bush�s sound fundamentals
statement and reality, showing the manufacturing sector in the key heartland of
the US is suffering its lowest output for seven years. "As far as this
indicator is concerned, a recession, and a severe one at that, is already
underway," said Paul Ash-worth, of Capital Economics. For Merrill Lynch,
the collapse in the outlook for activity six months out was even more worrisome
since it posted the steepest decline in the 40-year history of this report.
America�s
�new business cycle� which began in the 1980s has created, as Thomas Palley
former chief economist with the US-China Economic Security Review Commission
puts it, large trade deficits, manufacturing job loss, asset price inflation,
rising debt-to-income ratios, and detachment of wages from productivity growth.
It has used financial booms to support debt-financed spending, an easing of
credit standards to support borrowing, and cheap imports to ameliorate the
effects of wage stagnation. As Palley puts it, with �debt burdens elevated and
housing prices significantly above levels warranted by their historical
relation to income, the business cycle of the last two decades appears
exhausted.�
According
to The New York Times, the sound fundamentals Bush likes to refer to, are
alarmingly parallel to �Japan�s lost decade," when the Japanese economy,
after a long boom in the 1990s, was stopped by a sharp fall in the real estate
market causing a stretch of stagnation which ended only a few years ago. Clyde
V. Prestowitz, president of the Economic Strategy Institute in Washington, says
�the American economy is very fragile now,� a sentiment which is echoed by
Nouriel Roubini, an economics professor at the Stern School of Business at New
York University, who warns that �the roughly $100 billion in bad loans reported
by banks to date could increase nearly tenfold, as the defaults spread beyond
the subprime mortgage loans to consumer loans, credit cards and corporate
lending.�
European Central Bank council member Guy Quaden points
out that �it is clear that the slowdown in the U.S. will be more pronounced
than previously foreseen.� According to Bank of Italy governor Mario Draghi, in the
meeting held in Tokyo by the finance ministers and central bank chiefs of the Group
of Seven industrialized nations, "Bernanke said that while house prices
are falling, they can't say how long and deep the crisis will be." But as
lawmakers, politicians and bankers continue to debate about the current state
of the American economy, what is clear is that the latest consumer price index
(CPI), the government's main inflation indicator shows that for the year ending
in January, all prices were up 4.3 percent. Excluding the temporary surges
after Katrina, inflation hasn't been higher since July 1991. As for the
producer price index, year over year the PPI is up 7.4 percent the fastest pace
since 1981. As Robert Brusca, chief economist at FAO Economics says, with this
data at hand, �it will be hard for Mr. Bernanke to testify . . . and hold to
the fiction of inflation as under control and the Fed as master of tamed
inflation expectations."
Yet
Bernanke is telling lawmakers that `�inflation expectations appear to have
remained reasonably well anchored,� and George Bush is convinced that fundamentals
are in place.
As for now,
while talk of subprime exposure has diminished, Ted Wieseman, an economist at
Morgan Stanley, warns that �investor worries about potential further writedowns
are shifting in a big way from subprime residential mortgages to commercial
real estate lending.� Also as major retailers reported chilly January
same-store sales, Wal-Mart with a meager 0.5 percent increase, Target with a
1.1 percent drop, Macy's with a worse-than-expected 7.1 percent decline, Kohl's
with an 8.3 percent plunge and Nordstrom with a 6.6 percent drop in comps, the
National Federation of Independent Business said its index of small business
optimism slipped to the lowest reading since January 1991, when the U.S. was
mired in recession.
To add to
this economic and social carnage, Macy's Inc. has reported that it plans to cut
2,300 jobs across the country; Hasbro Inc., the second-largest U.S. toy
company, expects a 14 percent to 15 percent increase this year in the costs of
made in China products; Time Warner has reported a 41 percent decline in
fourth-quarter profits, Office Depot a 85 percent plunge in profit, and Jeffrey
Garten, professor of international trade and finance at Yale School of
Management has said that the
United States "is beginning to look like a bargain-basement."
Of course,
if the world�s economic engine looking like a bargain-basement is a reflection
of sound fundamentals, then I must accept my misreading of today�s economic
reality and subscribe to George Bush�s sound fundamentals equation.
Pablo Ouziel is a sociologist and a freelance
writer based in Spain.