Last Thursday, Alan Greenspan�s low-interest, �supply side�
bandwagon tipped over on Wall Street sending the Dow Jones into a 387-point
nosedive. In overnight trading in Europe and Asia, the equity-rout continued
despite the European Central Bank�s (ECB) unprecedented injection of 95 billion
euros ($135 billion) into the region�s banking system.
The ECB�s emergency action has had no manifest effect on the
slumping indexes. Global markets have been roiled by the dramatic downturn in
the US housing market and the subprime contagion which is unwinding trillions
of dollars of over-leveraged bets in the secondary market. There�s no doubt now
that the euphoric-days of easy money and soaring markets has come to come to an
end. In a matter of hours, Maestro Greenspan's Bull Market Sideshow
deteriorated into a full-blown credit crunch.
Mortgage blues
No one has summed up the disaster in the mortgage lending
business better than Paul Muolo of Broker Universe: �I'll put it
bluntly: if you operate a non-depository mortgage firm and don't have a
deep-pocketed parent or hedge fund as a sugar daddy you're likely to be out of
business by year-end, probably sooner. In the 20-plus years that I've been
covering residential finance I haven't seen a financial meltdown this swift
since the S&L crisis of the mid-to-late 1980s. One subprime executive who
closed his shop a few months ago told me, �This is a liquidity crunch the likes
I have never seen.� Meanwhile, the mudslide is rolling downhill from Wall
Street to mortgage bankers, to loan brokers, and then the consumer.�
�The mudslide from Wall Street.� That says it all.
In a matter of days, the credit markets have frozen, making
it impossible to secure financing on anything from a leveraged buyout (LBO) of
a major corporation to a meager home loan. The cheap money and easy credit have
vanished into the summer ether, leaving the investment banks holding $300 of
billion toxic debt they have no way of offloading.
It�s a real mess and there are no simple solutions. Lenders
are standing on the sidelines waiting for the next shoe to drop or the next
body to float to the surface. Deals are going undone; business is grinding to a
halt.
What were the geniuses at the Federal Reserve thinking when
they dropped rates to 1 percent and pumped out trillions of dollars that made
their way into �no document� liar�s loans to applicants with bad credit? Didn�t
they know there�d be a day of reckoning when the housing and credit bubbles
would smash into each other, taking down much of the US economy with them?
Was it an honest miscalculation or a sinister plot? Or,
maybe, it was just stupidity?
Who knows; who cares. Whatever it was; the aftershocks are
bound to be felt for a very long time. Decades maybe.
Warnings from China
The Chinese have added to the subprime woes by threatening
to dump their reserves of US dollars and US Treasuries if Congress passes
protectionist legislation.
According to MarketWatch, �A report in the U.K.'s Daily
Telegraph that China, the second-largest foreign holder of U.S. government debt
with $407 billion, is prepared to sell its holdings in the event of
U.S.-imposed trade sanctions. Japan owns $615 billion of Treasuries.�
That ought to stop Congress in a hurry. China has $1.3
trillion of US paper they can toss into the jet stream and crash the greenback
whenever they choose. That�s why they�ve stockpiled dollar-backed assets for
the last decade -- not because they like us. They don�t. They intend to use
their massive FOREX reserves like a cattle prod to keep us in line. That�s how
bankers always do it. And China is now America�s banker. That�s why it pays to
run the country the old fashioned way; by strengthening the manufacturing
sector, increasing exports and building up national savings. Debt is just the
fast track to slavery.
China is now calling the shots. If they even get a whiff of
US-imposed tariffs, they�ll bring the US economy to its knees. And there�s nothing
Congress can do about it, either. They�d be better off just pulling up a lawn
chair and watching as US jobs and wealth go chugging off to the Far East.
But China is probably the least of our worries. The looming
credit crunch is a much bigger immediate concern. The Wall Street Journal
provided a glimpse of a sudden breakdown in lending in an article earlier this
month: �Credit Chill Freezes Leveraged Deals,� Aug 3.
�The big chill gripping global credit markets has caused 46
leveraged financing deals around the world to be pulled since June 22,
representing more than $60 billion in funding that companies had planned for
mergers and acquisitions.
The number of deals pulled last year: zero.�
Another article put it like this: �The investment grade corporate
bond market has ground to a halt, making it difficult for companies to access
capital and hard for investors to find a place to put their money to work. . .
. The problems in the primary market could, if they persist, throw a wrench in
the workings of corporate America, making it tougher for companies to finance,
among other things, investments, buyouts and equity buybacks. . . . For July,
corporate bond issuance was down 77 percent from June.� (�Corporate Bond Market
has come to a Standstill,� Wall Street Journal)
Still, President Dumbo assures us, �There�s enough liquidity
in the system to allow markets to correct� and that �the U.S. economy remains
the envy of the world.�
Err, correction, �Was the envy of the world.�
The easy money is drying up, the big mergers are slowing
down and the hand-wringing in the front office has just begun. Next question:
How low can the stock market go?
At present valuations; stocks are vastly overpriced,
reflecting the inflationary pressures from our recycled $800 billion current
account deficit and the loony expansion of the money supply at the Federal
Reserve (now running at a whopping 13 percent). Presently, the stock market is
hanging on by its fingernails. One little gust of wind -- like a few more
collapsing hedge funds -- and the market will go somersaulting through deep
space.
The ISI Group�s Andy Laperriere put it like this: �It�s
worse than the most pessimistic assumptions. In these kinds of financial
corrections, it pays to expect more surprises.� (WSJ, Aug 6, 2007)
Still, even though the subprime contagion has spread to all
loan categories, the glut of homes continues to increase, and the mortgage
industry is flatlining on the emergency room floor; there is room for optimism.
Consider the comforting comments of Secretary of Treasury Henry Paulson:
"I don't think it [the subprime mess] poses any threat to the overall
economy. . . . .In an economy as diverse and healthy as this, losses may occur
in a number of institutions, but that overall this is contained and we have a
healthy economy."
�Contained?� This is �contained?�
Newsweek�s Daniel Gross had this reaction to Paulson�s
remarks: �If the containment policy of the Cold War worked as well as this
subprime-mess containment policy, we'd all be speaking Russian and living on
collective farms.�
Gross is right, we�ve only begun to see the spillover from
the housing fiasco. There�s plenty more carnage in the pipeline. Paulson needs
to stop blowing smoke and tell the truth.
�A self-reinforcing negative cycle�
Economy.com's head honcho, Mark Zandi, gave the best
overview of what lies ahead in the near term as credit becomes scarcer:
"There is a substantial risk that the mortgage market will devolve into a
self-reinforcing negative cycle. Mounting credit problems could beget more
restrictive underwriting standards, which would weigh heavily on the fragile
housing market as potential borrowers become unable to obtain credit, and
existing borrowers facing large payment resets are unable to refinance.
Foreclosures would mount, leading to weaker house prices, falling homeowners'
equity and even more substantial credit problems. The cycle repeats with more
intensity and the mortgage market corrections unravel into a crash."
The �Great Unwinding� appears to be taking place already and
can be expected to accelerate as inflationary pressures increase and the price
of oil -- which has gained 20 percent in the last three months -- continues its
upward trek. There are other concerns, too, besides the slump in housing sales
and falling stock market. The downstream effects of tight credit will hurt
retail sales and employment. We can anticipate a decline in both areas in the
next two quarters. Automakers have already reported the weakest sales in nine
years. There�s also been a steady erosion of investor confidence and a plunge
in consumer spending from 3.7 percent to 1.3 percent. Credit card debt
continues to soar, but that�s only because the poor American consumer is
strapped and has nowhere else to turn. He has no savings and his wages have
stagnated. What choice does he have except to use the plastic?
Some market analysts believe that the credit storm will pass
without inflicting too much damage. Don�t bet on it. The big picture is pretty
grim. Trading in mortgage-backed securities (MBSs) has slowed to a trickle
while the appetite for corporate bonds has nearly disappeared. No one really
knows how many trillions of dollars will be lost in funky mortgage-related
CDOs. But one thing is certain; the blowups in the hedge fund industry will
continue through the autumn and early winter. These are End Times for the fund
managers; they�d better make their ablutions and kiss their kids goodbye.
Still, the sudden reversal in the credit markets is not
without its lighter side. Jim Kunstler provided this witty summary of frantic
traders trying to sort through the current mess while still enjoying the waning
of summer: �One can only imagine the number of cell phone minutes racked up
this weekend out in the Hamptons by players trying desperately to finagle their
way out of the brutal fact that their firms and funds suddenly lay exposed to
the cruel ravages of reality. A lot of catered crab tidbits and mini-quiches
must have gone uneaten out along the dunes as weeping men in blazers realized that
"marked to market" had come to mean the same thing as 'holding a
bundle of shit.'"
�Weeping men in blazers.� Priceless. Later in the post,
Kunstler offers this synopsis of the subprime, CDO, �Ponzi-loan racket� which
is swirling through the financial markets like a tornado: �The whole racket
this time was designed to dissociate the loan contracts as far as possible from
their company of origin, and then to slice and dice the liabilities of
ownership so finely that all the lawyers theoretically ever producible in the
life of this universe, or several like it, may never succeed in patching
together a coherent skein of ultimate responsibility. In the meantime, a
remorseless chain of mere procedure in the form of default and foreclosure
notices issued by computers will be sent through the mail, and sheriff's
deputies will fan out through the subdivisions with their rolls of yellow tape,
tossing residents out on the street (if they haven't already mailed in their
keys to some company that fired all its employees and shuttered its offices
back in June).� (Clusterfuck Nation by Jim Kunstler)
As the banks tighten up their lending standards; the number
of business deals will drop accordingly and the economy will slow to a crawl.
This process is already underway. A few �Up Days� in the stock market mean
nothing. This is a Force-5 hurricane headed for a trailer park. Nothing will
slow it down. The problems are too deeply rooted -- the infection too far
along. The huge, overleveraged bets will progressively unravel and the economy
will go into freefall. It�s always painful when fundamentals reemerge and
economic gravity takes hold.
When credit markets freeze, consumers become wary of
spending too much, and the economy stalls. This is how deflationary cycles
begin. The Daily Reckoning�s Bill Bonner puts it like this: �The Fed is still
talking about the risk of inflation . . . while the risk of deflation rises
daily. Deflation happens when liquidity dries up. Suddenly, money disappears.
Lenders don�t lend. Spenders don�t spend. The velocity of money declines as
everyone holds on to what he�s got . . . fearful of losing it.
"When this happens even the feds can�t do much about
it. They have their printing presses . . . but they have no good way of getting
the money into the hands of people who will move it around. The usual way is
through the credit markets. The Federal Reserve pushes down short-term interest
rates, for example, enabling lenders to offer money at lower rates.
"But when a deflationary mentality takes hold of
people, the last thing they want to do is to borrow money. They�re afraid that
they might not be able to pay it back. Besides, in deflation, consumer prices
fall. . . . As prices fall, consumers become even more reluctant to spend. They
begin to see that they�ll get a better deal if they wait.� (Bill Bonner, �The
Daily Reckoning�)
�Spenders don�t spend. Lenders don�t lend.� That says it
all. People get scared and liquidity gets choked off at the source. This is the
�reinforcing negative cycle� which ends in Depression. The only way it can be
avoided is by central banks quickly taking action and priming the economic pump
with cheap credit that stimulates economic activity. But the Fed doesn�t want
to lower rates because foreign investment will flee the country and put the
greenback in a fatal swoon.
According to reports on the
Internet, the Bank of Canada has assured �financial market participants and
the public that it will provide liquidity to support the stability of the Canadian
financial system and the continued functioning of financial markets.�
This sounds serious.
And a similar report on Bloomberg: �The European Central
Bank, in an unprecedented response to a sudden demand for cash from banks
roiled by the subprime mortgage collapse in the U.S., loaned 94.8 billion euros
($130 billion) to assuage a credit crunch. . . . The ECB said it would provide
unlimited cash as the fastest increase in overnight Libor since June 2004
signaled banks are reducing the supply of money just as investors retreat
because of losses from the U.S. real-estate slump.� (�ECB
Offers Unlimited Cash as Bank Lending Costs Soar,� Bloomberg News, Aug 9)
Hmmmmm. Has the light started blinking red yet?
Credit crunch: Out of the pan, into the fire
The impending credit crisis can�t be avoided, but it could
be mitigated by taking radical steps to soften the blow. Emergency changes to
the federal tax code could put more money in the hands of maxed-out consumers
and keep the economy sputtering along while efforts are made to curtail the
ruinous trade deficit. We should eliminate the Social Security tax for any
couple making under $60,000 per year and restore the 1953 tax-brackets for
America�s highest earners so that the upper 1 percent, who have benefited the
most from the years of prosperity, will be required to pay 93 percent of all
earnings above the first $1 million income. At the same time, corporate profits
should be taxed at a flat 35 percent, while capital gains should be locked in
at 35 percent. No loopholes. No exceptions.
Congress should initiate a program of incentives for
reopening American factories and provide generous subsidies to rebuild US
manufacturing. The emphasis should be on reestablishing a competitive market
for US exports while developing the new technologies which will address the
imminent problems of environmental degradation, global warming, peak oil,
overpopulation, resource scarcity, disease and food production. Offshoring of
American jobs should be penalized by tariffs levied against the offending
industries.
The oil and natural gas industries should be nationalized
with the profits earmarked for vocational training, free college tuition, universal
health care and improvements to the nation�s infrastructure.
Unfortunately, these issues cannot be resolved within the
framework of the current political model -- the system has been thoroughly
corrupted by private interest and corporate money. The feudal system of
predatory capitalism is incompatible with democratic values, civil liberties,
and basic human needs. Ending the two party duopoly would be a good place to
start -- along with public funding of political campaigns. Then we can begin the
serious work creating a world where environmental protection, human rights, and
economic justice have a chance to flourish.
Credit meltdown: Another Katrina?
Neither Bush nor his colleagues at the Federal Reserve will
use the present crisis to bring about the sweeping changes that would
strengthen the middle class, build confidence in the financial system, or
eliminate inequities in the present distribution of wealth. Instead, they will
choose the path of least resistance, that is, Bernanke will eventually lower
interest rates and set off a hyperinflationary cycle that will destroy the
currency, strip workers and pensioners of their savings and retirements, and
plunge the country into Third World poverty.
Inflation is the purest form of class warfare. That�s why we
can say, with some degree of certainty, that it will be George Bush�s first
choice.
Mike
Whitney lives in Washington state. He can be reached at fergiewhitney@msn.com.