It�s been almost five months since the first report that
Israeli drone aircraft have been dropping a �mystery weapon� on Palestinians in
the Gaza Strip. Since then, news media around the world have run stories
depicting the strange and �horrific� wounds inflicted by the new bomb. The
international press has spoken with Palestinian doctors and medics who say
Israel�s new device is a kind of chemical weapon that has significantly
increased the fatality rate among the victims of Israeli attacks. [1] [2]
In mid-October, Italian investigators reported forensic
evidence that suggests the new weapon may also represent the near future of US
�counterinsurgency warfare.� Combined with photographs of the victims and
testimony from attending doctors, this evidence points to the use of Dense
Inert Metal Explosives (DIME). [3]
DIME is an LCD (�low collateral damage�) weapon developed at
the US Air Force Research Laboratory. Publicly, it is slated for initial
deployment in 2008. DIME bombs produce an unusually powerful blast within a
relatively small area, spraying a superheated �micro-shrapnel� of powdered Heavy
Metal Tungsten Alloy (HMTA). Scientific studies have found that HMTA is
chemically toxic, damages the immune system, rapidly causes cancer, and attacks
DNA (genotoxic). [4-11]
It is unfortunate that the US media have virtually blacked
out the story of Israel�s new weapon, not least because our own military may
soon be using it in Iraq and Afghanistan. The story might also have told us
something about the grossly disproportionate brutality of Israel�s war on the
Palestinian people -- reason enough for the media to suppress it. [12]
Thanks to the intrepid Italians, the story could even have
introduced Americans to their government�s DIME weapons program. This
three-part article will ask whether Israel is �testing� US DIME bombs in the
Gaza Strip, and explore the workings, dangers, and projected use of DIME
weapons and their roots in depleted uranium (DU) research. These parallels will
lead us to consider DIME in its historical context, as the latest innovation in
the US military�s long-running development of genotoxic weapons.
�They cannot return to life again�
The first reports about �Israel�s new weapon� came from Dr
Joma Al-Saqqa, chief of the emergency unit at Gaza�s largest hospital,
Al-Shifa. Dr. Al-Saqqa said that Israel was using �a new �chemical� weapon� and
its siege was �a live exercise on a new ammunition that, so far, has resulted
in killing 50 Palestinians and injuring 200.� He observed that, �despite the
damage in internal soft tissue in the bodies of injured people, the fragments
were not detected by X-ray. In other words, they had disappeared or dissolved
inside the body.� [13]
�There were usually entry and exit wounds,� Dr. Al-Saqqa
reported. �When the wounds were explored no foreign material was found. There
was tissue death, the extent of which was difficult to determine. . . . A
higher deep infection rate resulted with subsequent amputation. In spite of
amputation there was a higher mortality.� The effects of the weapon seemed
�radioactive.� [14] [15]
According to Palestine News Network, Dr. Al-Saqqa �confirmed
that there were dozens of wounded legs and arms. Many of them had been burned
from the inside, and distorted to the point that they cannot return to life
again.� [16]
�When the shrapnel hit[s] the body, it causes very strong
burns that destroy the tissues around the bones . . . it burns and destroys
internal organs, like the liver, kidneys, and the spleen and other organs and
makes saving the wounded almost impossible. As a surgeon, I have seen thousands
of wounds during the Intifada, but nothing was like this weapon.� [17]
However, Dr. Al-Saqqa could not analyze the chemistry of the
bizarre wounds. On the first day of the siege, June 27, Israel had conveniently
destroyed Gaza�s only crime laboratory. [18]
Despite his pleas to the �international community� to
investigate and lend assistance in treating the victims, �no one has lifted a
finger,� the doctor was quoted in mid-July. �What we found were journalists who
came to take pictures, but as for the medical community, nothing.� [19]
On August 3, the United Nations Relief and Works Agency
(UNRWA) reported that Commissioner-General Karen AbuZayd had visited Dr.
Al-Saqqa�s hospital, �where the staff is struggling to deal with wounds
resulting in an unusually high number of amputations.� Commissioner AbuZayd
commented that �what we saw in Al-Shifa . . . was rather horrific.� [20]
According to Merlin (Medical Emergency Relief
International), �75 per cent of war-wounded patients admitted at one hospital
needed amputations� following an Israeli attack on Gaza City. [21]
The World Health Organization was reportedly considering an
investigation into the injuries. Physicians for Human Rights - Israel �agreed
to take away fragments of tissue from the bodies of Palestinians killed during
the recent military operations in Gaza for possible analysis in Israel but
urged the medics to seek an international investigation.� [22]
Tungsten in tissue samples: A DIME weapon?
On October 19, Italy�s Rai24news televised an investigative
report that supplied crucial new information. The Italian investigators had
tissue samples from the victims in Gaza analyzed by Dr. Carmela Vaccaio at
University Parma. Dr. Vaccaio reportedly found �a very high concentration of
carbon and the presence of unusual materials, such as copper, aluminum and
tungsten.� The doctor concluded that her "findings could be in line with
the hypothesis that the weapon in question is DIME."
Rai24news reporters also talked to Maj. Gen. Yitzhak
Ben-Israel, former chief of the Israeli Defense Force's (IDF's) weapons
development program. General Ben-Israel appeared to be familiar with DIME
weapons. He explained that "one of the ideas is to allow those targeted to
be hit without causing damage to bystanders or other persons." [23]
The US Air Force refers to this emerging realm of weaponry
as FLM (Focused Lethality Munitions). FLM is expected to provide the �weapons
of choice� for targeting �terrorists hiding among civilians,� as a cheerleading
Wall Street Journal article put it. [24]
With �focused lethality [and] higher energy materials . . . nano
particles, intelligent fuzing, [and] mass focus lethality,� the Air Force �will
be able to strike effectively, wherever and whenever necessary, with minimal
collateral damage.� Ominously, the military thinks these weapons will allow it
to target sites "previously off limits to the warfighter." [25] [26]
This warfare of the future is reminiscent of what Israel has
been doing for years, but with one-ton bombs, 155-mm artillery shells, and
tank-fired antipersonnel flechette bombs. Are FLM weapons like DIME an
improvement? Or will they actually increase civilian casualties and suffering,
and mimic depleted uranium weapons by inducing disease and genetic damage in
their victims? These disturbing questions will be explored in the next
installment of this article.
References
1) Palestinian
injuries suggest Israel is using chemical weapons in Gaza, Ma'an News,
7/10/2006
2) Israel used
chemical weapons in Lebanon and Gaza, Jean Shaoul, wsws.org, 10/24/2006
3) Italian TV:
Israel used new weapon prototype in Gaza Strip, Ha'aretz, 10/19/2006
4) Dense
Inert Metal Explosive (DIME), GlobalSecurity.org, 10/18/2006
5) Abstract:
Potential late health effects of depleted uranium and tungsten used in
armor-piercing munitions: comparison of neoplastic transformation and
genotoxicity with the known carcinogen nickel, Miller, AC, et al, PubMed,
11/26/2006
6) Neoplastic
transformation of human osteoblast cells to the tumorigenic phenotype by heavy
metal�tungsten alloy particles: induction of genotoxic effects, Miller, AC,
et al, Carcinogenesis, Vol. 22, No. 1, 115-125, January 2001, Oxford University
Press
7) Abstract:
Carcinogenic Potential of Depleted Uranium and Tungsten Alloys, Alexandra C
Miller, Ph. D., Department Of Defense, Armed Forces Radiobiology Research
Institute (AFRRI)
8) Depleted
uranium-catalyzed oxidative DNA damage: absence of significant, alpha particle
decay, Miller, AC, et al, Journal of Inorganic Biochemistry, Issue 91, 2002
pp. 246� 252
9) Embedded
Weapons-Grade Tungsten Alloy Shrapnel Rapidly Induces Metastatic High-Grade
Rhabdomyosarcomas in F344 Rats, Kalinich et al, Environmental Health
Perspectives Volume 113, Number 6, June 2005
10) Abstract: Effect
of the militarily-relevant heavy metals, depleted uranium and heavy metal
tungsten-alloy on gene expression in human liver carcinoma cells (HepG2),
Miller, AC, et al, SpringerLink/Molecular and Cellular Biochemistry, 1/1/2004
11) Preconceptional
paternal exposure to radiation or heavy metals like cadmium can induce cancer
in unexposed offspring, Alexandra C. Miller, Rafael Rivas, Robert J. Merlot
and Paul, Carcinogenesis 5: Environmental and Endogenous Carcinogens/Proc Amer
Assoc Cancer Res, Volume 47, 2006
12) If Americans
Knew
13) Israel
'is using chemical ammunition' in Gaza, Duraid Al Baik, Centre for Research on
Globalization/Gulf News, 6/13/2006
14) Are New Weapons Being
Used In Gaza and Lebanon?, David Halpin MB BS FRCS, Electronic Intifada,
8/14/2006
15) Ministry
of Health report on toxic Israeli weapons confirmed by Gaza City medical
sources, Palestine News Network, 7/13/2006
16) ibid.
17) Doctors Report
Unusual Weapon Used in Gaza, Pacifica/Free
Speech Radio News 7/11/2006
18) Israel
'is using chemical ammunition' in Gaza, Centre for Research on
Globalization/Gulf News, 6/13/2006
19) Ministry
of Health report on toxic Israeli weapons confirmed by Gaza City medical
sources, Palestine News Network, 7/13/2006
20) UNRWA Commissioner-General Karen AbuZayd: "Please
don't forget what's going on in Gaza," ReliefWeb/UNRWA, 8/3/2006
21) Hospitals in Gaza
overwhelmed and running out of supplies, Electronic Intifada/Merlin,
8/8/2006
22) Gaza
doctors encounter 'unexplained injuries', Donald Macintyre,
The Independent 9/4/2006
23) Italian TV:
Israel used new weapon prototype in Gaza Strip, Ha'aretz, 10/12/2006
24) Air Force seeks a
bomb with less bang, Greg Jaffe, The Wall Street Journal/Pittsburgh
Post-Gazette, 4/11/2006
25) Munition Technology
Drivers, Col. Thomas �Mas� Masiell, Air Force Research Laboratory,
12/1/2006
26) USAF
Unfunded Priority List (UPL), SAF/FMB POC, FY 2007, February 2006, Page 54
Part 2
James
Brooks serves as webmaster for Vermonters for a
Just Peace in Palestine/Israel. He can be contacted at jamiedb@wildblue.net.