When President George W. Bush spoke to the nation last week,
he alluded to the fact that the Iraq war will be continuing when he is out of
office. Every Democratic presidential candidate says they believe invading Iraq
was a mistake, despite what their voting record may indicate. Each one has a
plan to redeploy troops. There are two factors to consider concerning the
Democratic presidential candidates and Iraq:
- Did he/she
vote to authorize the use of military force against Iraq in 2002? If the
candidate was not a member of Congress in 2002, did he/she speak out
against invading Iraq?
- What is
his/her plan to redeploy U.S. troops out of Iraq?
Senator Barack Obama touts the fact that he did not vote to
authorize the use of military force against Iraq in 2002. He revealed his most
extensive plan to bring troops home from Iraq on September 12. Obama�s plan
would remove one or two combat brigades in Iraq per month. Presently there are
20 brigades in Iraq, and General Petraeus committed to reducing them to 15 by
next summer. Only 10 brigades would be in Iraq by next summer under Obama�s
plan.
Unlike Obama, former Senator John Edwards voted to authorize
the use of military force against Iraq. However, while speaking at the
California Democratic Convention in April Edwards said, �I voted for this war
and I was wrong to vote for this war. I should have never voted for this war.�
Edwards� plan to end the war requires a �major diplomatic
effort� which would �engage in direct talks with all the nations in the
region,� and give support for a �political solution to the sectarian violence
inside Iraq, including through convening a multi-party peace conference.�
Edwards� plan calls for Congress to take four legislative actions:
- Cap
funding for troops at 100,000 �to stop the surge and implement an
immediate drawdown of 40-50,000 combat troops.�
- Prohibit
any funding to deploy new troops to Iraq �that do not meet real readiness
standards and that have not been properly trained and equipped.�
- Repeal
the authorization it gave Bush in 2002 to deploy combat troops.
- Require
total withdrawal of combat troops in �about a year without leaving behind
any permanent U.S. military bases in Iraq.
Senator Hillary Clinton also voted to authorize the use of
military force against Iraq. Until this year, Clinton did not express regret
concerning her vote. In 2004 Clinton said she did not regret her affirmative
vote, �No, I don't regret giving the president authority because at the time it
was in the context of weapons of mass destruction, grave threats to the United
States, and clearly, Saddam Hussein had been a real problem for the
international community for more than a decade.�
During a Democratic presidential candidates debate Clinton
said, �I take responsibility for my vote. Obviously I did as good a job I could
at the time. It was a sincere vote based on the information available to me.
And I've said many times that if I knew then what I now know, I would not have
voted that way.�
In July Clinton announced her plan for Iraq, which consists
of three actions:
- Begin
phased redeployment within her first days in office.
- Secure
Iraq�s stability as troops withdraw.
- Convening
a �regional stabilization group� within her first days in office with
global powers, key allies, and the nation�s which border Iraq to �develop
and implement a strategy to create a stable Iraq.
Senator
Joseph Biden, Jr., also voted to authorize the use of military force, but he
now speaks out against the Bush administration�s handling of the war. Biden has
consistently voted against bills which set a timetable for withdrawing from
Iraq. In a February 2007 speech, he spoke about his plan for Iraq: �Our plan
recognizes that there is no purely military exit strategy from Iraq. Instead,
we set out a roadmap to a political settlement in Iraq -- one that gives its
warring factions a way to share power peacefully and offers us a chance to
leave with our interests intact.�
Biden developed a plan for Iraq with Les Gelb, the president
emeritus of the Council on Foreign Relations. The Biden/Gelb plan consists of
five steps:
- Establish
One Iraq, with Three Regions: Iraq would have a limited federal government
with three autonomous regions (Shiite, Sunni, and Kurd).
- Share
Oil Revenues: The federal government of Iraq would set national oil
policy, ensuring that revenues are distributed among the three regions.
- Convene
International Conference, Enforce Regional Non-Aggression Pact: With the
U.S. a regional security conference would be convened with Iraq�s
neighbors.
- Responsibly
Drawdown US Troops: Develop a plan to withdraw U.S. military forces from
Iraq by the end of 2007, but keep a residual force of about 20,000 troops
in Iraq.
- Increase
Reconstruction Assistance and Create a Jobs Program: Provide
reconstruction assistance in Iraq, and insist other countries lead in
financing reconstruction.
Although Senator Chris Dodd (CT) voted to authorize the use
of military force against Iraq, he told ABC News in January that he regrets his
vote. As early as October 2003, Dodd expressed his misgivings about the
invasion of Iraq. His plan to end the war in Iraq is based on the amendment he
co-sponsored with Senators Russ Feingold and Harry Reid. The amendment, which
was defeated, would begin redeploying U.S. troops from Iraq within 120 days and
would complete redeployment by April 30, 2008.
One of the first former U.S. senators to publicly oppose the
use of military force against Iraq, Maurice �Mike� Gravel pointed out during
the June debate for Democratic presidential candidates that the war in Iraq was
�facilitated by Democrats.� He stated during another debate that he would
�commence an immediate and orderly withdrawal of all U.S. troops that will have
them home within 60 days.� He reasoned that the �sooner U.S. troops are
withdrawn, the sooner we can pursue aggressive diplomacy to bring an end to the
civil war that currently consumes Iraq.�
Rep. Dennis Kucinich, like Obama, voted against authorizing
the use of force against Iraq. On February 28, he introduced House Resolution
1234, calling it �a plan to end the war in Iraq, which calls on the
international community to provide peacekeepers and security forces that will
move in as our troops leave.� The exact text of the resolution states, �the
United States should end the occupation of Iraq immediately, simultaneously
with the introduction of a United Nations-led international peacekeeping force
pursuant to an agreement with nations within the region.� The resolution also
called for all U.S. contractors and sub-contractors in Iraq to �return . . . turn
over all contracting work to the Iraqi Government.� Referred to the House
committees on Armed Services and Foreign Affairs, the resolution has not yet
been voted on.
Elected as governor of New Mexico in 2002, Bill Richardson
has consistently spoken against the invasion and occupation of Iraq. He
developed what he terms a �Seven Point Plan for Iraq.� The plan consists of the
following points:
- De-authorize
the war now. Congress should pass a resolution which de-authorizes the war
�under Article I of the US Constitution and the War Powers Act.�
- Troops
out in six months. Congress should set a date to pull out all military
troops, and appropriate funds for the withdrawal and redeployment of
troops.
- No
residual forces left behind. All troops should be withdrawn, with no
�residual forces left in Iraq.�
- Promote
Iraq reconciliation. An Iraqi Reconciliation Conference should be promoted
by the U.S. which would �bring the factions together to seek compromises
and to begin confidence-building measures, including the end of militia
violence.�
- Work
with all neighbors and allies. A regional conference should be convened
�to secure the cooperation of all neighbors . . . in promoting peace and
stability.� The key objectives of the conference would be �guarantees of
non-interference, as well as the creation of a multilateral force of UN
peacekeepers.� The multilateral force would be comprised mostly of
�non-US, primarily Muslim troops.�
- Global
cooperation in reconstruction. A donor conference should be convened to
�fund Iraq�s reconstruction.�
- Redeploy
to address real threats. Troops must be redeployed to Afghanistan �to stop
the resurgence of the Taliban and to fight the real terrorists who
attacked this country on 9-11.�
For more information on the candidates:
Vote-smart.org
OnTheIssues.org
BarackObama.com
Obama.senate.gov
HillaryClinton.com
Clinton.senate.gov
JohnEdwards.com
JoeBiden.com
Biden.senate.gov
ChrisDodd.com
Dodd.senate.gov
Grave12008.us
Dennis4President.com
Kucinich.house.gov
Richardsonforpresident.com