The real winner in the November 7 election is the grassroots
voter protection movement.
That the well-oiled, well-funded Rove/Bush theft machine
lost control of the US House with the Senate as close as it is says just one
thing: somebody was watching. In 2006, that would be thousands of volunteer
grassroots activists who left no stone unturned to expose rigged voting machines,
Jim Crow registration roadblocks, trashed provisional ballots, manipulated
absentee voting processes, and much more.
A nationwide movement has been born to apply the lessons of
the stolen elections of 2000, 2002 and 2004. In the lead-up to 2006, activists
and independent experts scrutinized voting machines and electoral processes as
never before. Mainstream media reports from The New York Times to CNN's Lou
Dobbs to hundreds of radio talk shows finally paid attention to
"glitches" and "problems" and "long lines" and
"disputes" that just an election cycle ago were dismissed as
"business as usual" or the stuff of conspiracy theory.
At least six major reports have now warned of the
hackability of electronic voting machines. More than 90 percent of the American
public has expressed concern about the sanctity of the US electoral system. At
least two state governors have called for electronic voting machines to be
discarded in favor of a return to paper ballots.
As we write, in Montana the fate of the U.S. Senate rests on
a hand count after a software failure on voting machines in a few remaining
precincts. [Editor's note: Democrat Jon Tester has been declared the winner
over the GOP's incumbent, Senator Conrad Burns, now tying the Senate at 50-50
with Virginia still to be decided.]]
The impact? There is no way the 2006 election would not have
been stolen without a concerted 50-state effort to guarantee otherwise.
In Ohio, an unprecedented project by five statewide Green,
Libertarian and independent candidates dispersed scores of election observers
throughout the state, placing them inside key county boards of elections and
precincts.
A classic case comes from central Ohio, "scene of the
crime" for the 2004 election. In the 15th Congressional District, election
protection attorney Cliff Arnebeck was initially turned away from voting due to
lack of "proper I.D," even though he presented a valid Ohio driver's
license and proof of his current address.
Arnebeck serves as lead attorney in the King Lincoln lawsuit
that has won preservation of the Ohio 2004 ballots and a number of key
victories regarding election protection. All around him, hundreds of voters
were being wrongly forced to show various forms of personal identification.
Election observers documented a staggering percent of voters who were being
forced to cast provisional ballots. Provisionals are notoriously easy for GOP
Secretary of State J. Kenneth Blackwell to pitch or now delete from the
e-voting machines. More than 16,000 of them, mostly on paper, remain uncounted
from 2004.
Clearly, this was set up to be a stolen cakewalk for
incumbent Congresswoman Deborah Pryce (R-15th), fourth ranking House Republican
and a close Bush ally.
Instead, Pryce's alleged margin of victory is now less than
4,000 votes. Rather than conceding, challenger Mary Jo Kilroy has vowed to
fight it out until the last ballot is counted. A Democratic poll watcher at the
Ohio Student Union at Ohio State University estimated that as many as 50
percent of the students may have been forced to vote provisional ballots. These
student voters are in the heart of the undecided race in the 15th district, and
early reports indicate there are 20-40,000 uncounted e-provisional voters in
that race.
Around the country, races in at least eight states are still
under extreme scrutiny. Lawsuits are being prepared, videotape reviewed,
testimony collected, reports compiled. Numerous eyewitness accounts have been
filed at democracy@freepress.org, with CommonCause and a wide range of other election
protection web, phone and legal operations. Both Democrats and Republicans who
might earlier have meekly conceded are now holding out until the very last vote
is recounted.
This is new to American politics. In years gone by,
elections have been stolen and the populace -- and even candidates, like John
Kerry in 2004 -- have shrugged their shoulders.
No more. Team Bush/Rove has taught the grassroots that our
electoral process cannot be taken for granted.
One major, hopefully temporary, casualty in 2006 has been
exit polling. Exit polls have become the most reliable overall monitor on
election outcomes. The are regularly within 0.1 percent of the official vote
count in Germany. In 2004, they showed clearly that John Kerry won Ohio and the
national popular vote. They've been used to guarantee and even overturn dubious
results in Ukraine, Mexico, ex-Soviet Georgia, the Philippines and more.
But in 2006 the major networks did their best to lock up
exit polls results that might have embarrassed the White House. Instead, the
exit poll results were impounded under lock and key, to be released to the
public only after the election, and after "experts" massage the data
to make it match official vote counts. To this day, the core data from the 2004
exit polls has yet to be released to the public.
This cannot be allowed to stand. In the upcoming 2008
election, exit polls must be made fully public well before the final vote
counts are announced. They must be within one percent accuracy or better, and
their raw data must be a matter of open public record.
In the interim, the science of election protection will
advance and spread. There is still no reliable way to monitor electronic voting
machines, whose computer codes are still deemed private property, and held in
secret. Before 2008, this practice must be abolished. As the Rev. Jesse Jackson
has put it, there can be no public elections on privately controlled machines.
A return to paper ballots is the bottom line. The
color-coded, multi-shaped Swiss sequencing ballots would work perfectly fine
here in the U.S., and would save the nation billions of dollars, as well as the
hard uncertainty that surrounds our electoral process.
But however we cut it, there has been a sea change in the
election process.
As Americans, we have too long taken for granted the right
to vote and have our votes counted.
Now we know we have to fight for that right. And that doing
so has already helped turn the tide of American politics.
This article originally appeared in The Free Press.
Bob
Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman are co-authors, with Steve Rosenfeld, of WHAT
HAPPENED IN OHIO: A DOCUMENTARY RECORD OF THEFT AND FRAUD IN THE 2004 ELECTION,
just published by the New Press. Fitrakis is of counsel, and Wasserman is a
plaintiff, in the King Lincoln lawsuit. Fitrakis is an independent candidate
for governor, endorsed by the Green Party; Wasserman is author of SOLARTOPIA!
OUR GREEN-POWERED EARTH, a.d.
2030, available via www.solartopia.org.