On June 25, the Caucus on Freedom of the Press held a forum
on the state of journalism in the United States in the Congressional Visitors
Center in Washington, DC. The forum was organized by Representatives Adam
Schiff (D-CA) and Mike Pence (R-IN), two of the founding members of the caucus.
A panel of three journalists discussed a number of the
problems facing journalism. The Washington Post�s Bob Woodward, who was
slated to appear, was not able to attend.
Former Los Angeles Times reporter Tom Rosenstiehl
cited three points about the currently changing news media. The first is that
since crooked politicians, fraudsters, and other individuals worthy of news
investigations are doing their jobs full-time, there is also a need for
journalists to do their jobs full-time in covering such targets of
investigative journalism.
Rosenstiehl�s second point was the need for independent
journalism. He stated that people who are well financed and have
vested business interests would like to ensure that news on their activities,
especially at the state level, comport to those special business interests.
Third, Rosenstiehl said that the ethics of the press must be
maintained with a focus on accuracy and timely dissemination of news for public
discussion. He stressed that a difference must be maintained between
journalists and activists and noted that while the reportorial press is
shrinking the discussant press is growing. Rosenstiehl pointed out that in the
era of the Internet, there is a need for �smart aggregators� who can provide
readers with concise stories without a need for them to go to Google and wade
through thousands of accounts of the same story.
In answer to a question of what will become of the daily
local newspaper, Rick Edmonds, formerly with the St. Petersburg Times
and now with the Poynter Institute, answered that small community
news-based websites with affiliated print offerings are springing up in many
small communities across the country.
Steve Coll, formerly of The
Washington Post, bemoaned the fact that many local and state governmental
hearing rooms see very few journalists showing up these days to cover matters
of great public importance.
When asked about a possible solution for the problems of
newspapers, Coll suggested one solution would be for newspapers to become
non-profit public trusts in the same manner that the Poynter Institute kept
afloat The St. Petersburg Times.
However, Coll cited the lack of clarity in the tax law and posed the question
-- Do newspapers comply with 501(c)3 non-profit status? Coll urged Congress to
change the tax laws to allow newspapers to become 501(c)3 entities and still be
able to accept commercial advertisements.
Coll also said he believed the Federal Communications
Commission should award licenses for scarce broadcast spectrum to those who
serve the public interest. He thought that reduced FCC fees would be one way to
support independent broadcast reporting. Coll also believes that arms-length
funding streams budgeted for by Congress could replace corporate funds being
lost for journalism. He cited the Corporation for Public Broadcasting as a
potential model for Congress to fund independent journalism. Lastly, Coll
thought a presidential commission authorized by Congress should be established
to ensure public broadcasting reform continues to provide for local and
independent journalism across media platforms, including television, radio,
print, and Internet and provide assurances that government-funded media
entities are innovating with new media, including citizen reporting via cell
phone video and photographs and Twitter.
The entire forum was focused heavily on how to save
corporate print media from extinction.
Some of the panelists nostalgically hearkened back to the
days when newspaper monopolies and duopolies in cities across the nation acted
as gatekeepers for news reporting. However, that brand of journalism either is
dead or is dying across the nation.
Gatekeeping is one aspect of journalism that is happily
becoming extinct with new technology. Recently, The State of Columbia,
South Carolina, released e-mails exchanged between South Carolina Republican
Governor Mark Sanford and his Argentine girlfriend after sitting on them for
six months. Fox News was caught sitting on a letter sent to its anchor
Megyn Kelly by a former staffer for Nevada Republican Senator John Ensign that
described an illicit affair between Ensign and the former staffer�s wife. These
two blatant examples of gatekeeping are a major reason why big
corporate media should not receive one cent of federal money, either in the
forms of tax breaks, incentives, reduced FCC fees, or grants.
This editor pointed to one area where Congress can help
online journalists who are very much different from bloggers due to the
fact that bloggers are usually not full-time journalists. I recommended
to Representative Schiff that online journalists be separated from generic
bloggers for purposes of press accreditation and the issuance of credentials.
In so doing, online journalists would be afforded the same degree of access
that is granted by the congressional press galleries to print and broadcast
media.
In Washington, DC, access is a lifeblood issue and I pointed
out to Representative Schiff that many online journalists, including this one,
transitioned from print to the web some time ago but lost accredited access in
the process. I also said that the Caucus on Freedom of the Press could jointly
call on President Obama to ensure that the White House Press Office, as well as
those of departments such as Defense and State, open up their long-term
credentialing process to more online journalists. Representative Schiff said he
appreciated being made aware of the importance of having a level playing field
for official access for online journalists.
Previously
published in the Wayne
Madsen Report.
Copyright � 2009 WayneMadenReport.com
Wayne
Madsen is a Washington, DC-based investigative journalist and
nationally-distributed columnist. He is the editor and publisher of the Wayne Madsen Report
(subscription required).