On a hot, windy day in May, Liz and Garrett Perry of
Waterloo, Wisconsin, were disposing of scrap lumber at the Deer Track Park
landfill near Interstate 94 when a featherless, debeaked hen limped in front of
their pickup truck.
Oh that, said landfill workers. Live hens often come out of
the construction bins Creekwood Farm brings here with spent laying hens they've
In June, unwary canoers on Raccoon Creek near Sac City,
Iowa, paddled upon 31 dead pigs. Authorities found 100 more close by -- dumped
by a local farrowing operation when they died en route to the finishing
Factory farming isn't just a nightmare -- it's a nightmare
for PR professionals trying to defend it!
Just ask Aaron Putze, executive director of Coalition to
Support Iowa�s Farmers (CSIF), a group formed to "grow new and existing
livestock enterprises and navigate regulations and siting."
A native Iowan who says he remembers when manure management
was ''sloped concrete and a 3-inch rain," Putze contends, "Fifty hogs
and a couple dairy cows isn't going to send kids to college today.''
But other Iowa natives regard CSIF's activities -- it helped
Andy Muff of Ventura upsize the family farm to a 4,000 "contract finishing
operation" and Wendell Davison of Garner grow from 150 to 11,000 pigs --
as not neighborly.
"I have no problem smelling manure from our 90 head
cow/calf operation or our 450 hogs. 5,000 in one yard is a different
story," posts a farmer from southwest Iowa on the Des Moines Register web
site. "It is a common occurrence that one of their employees will drive
down the road with a full load of manure and accidentally open the back hatch
dumping manure on the road for quite some distance. Or we'll see a dead steer
laying in a field for a week or two eventually rotting into the earth."
"I wouldn't call a 6,000 cow dairy funded by investor
money with many low-wage employees a family farm," writes a self-described
young Iowan farmer on his blog.
CSIF will "save family farmers by converting them into
Hog House janitors," writes another Des Moines Register poster, cutting to
In fact, four busloads of anti-factory farm Iowans, many of
them farmers, converged on Putze's west Des Moines house in July, planting
a "bad neighbor" award on his lawn.
Nor have Karl Rove or Tony Snow expressed interest in CSIF
Similar sentiment greeted representatives from the National
Pork Board and Monsanto in Vernon County, Wisconsin, in July, when farmers
rolled more than 50 tractors and farm implements to a county board meeting to
support an ordinance banning new large-scale livestock operations.
And Ohio Fresh Eggs, when it resumed operations
in Croton after being shut down by the Department of Agriculture, to the
dismay of neighbor Richard Woodgeard says his grandchildren need to carry
flyswatters in the house when they visit him.
Nor has spin doctoring worked in Arizona where Hormel
subsidiary Pigs for Farmer John is trying to build a 52,800-pig facility in
Thousands of pigs can be raised without pollution, said
Michael Terrill, Pigs for Farmer John vice president, while giving a tour of
the company's pig facility in Snowflake, which generates flies and odor for
miles, according to the Arizona Republic.
But when farmers, neighboring landowners and
environmentalists heard the facility would use 7.8 billion gallons of water and
produce 28 million gallons of manure to be spread (or is that
"fertilize"?) on 2,500 acres of virgin desert they said you're
building what? Construction has been temporarily halted.
There is also the issue of animal care.
Confinement of thousands of animals in small spaces isn't
cruel, says Terrill, who is a veterinarian, because, "If we're not taking
care of that animal, they're not going to take care of us."
But his good-care-through-self-interest argument falters
when considering the 20,000 Smithfield hogs that drowned in their pens during
Hurricane Floyd and egg farms like Creekwood that routinely destroy spent hens.
And farmers like Jan and Nancy Pannekoek of Chilliwack, BC,
and Lynn Peters of Flora, Indiana. who let their hogs perish not once but TWICE
in recent hog barn fires -- Peters losing over 3,300.
"We'll get through this," he told the local paper,
no doubt planning to raise more hogs.
Martha Rosenberg is a Staff Cartoonist at the Evanston
Roundtable. Her work has appeared in the Chicago Tribune, LA Times, San
Francisco Chronicle, Boston Globe, Providence Journal. Arizona Republic, New
Orleans Times-Picayune and other newspapers. She can be reached at: firstname.lastname@example.org.