Whatever happened
to good old fashioned diplomacy? If you listen to the rhetoric of some world
leaders today, you can almost imagine them in short trousers exchanging insults
over the ownership of a lollipop. Except in this not so brave New World Order
there are people's lives and livelihoods at stake.
There are none more
juvenile than that of the self-appointed leader of the free world with his
"wanted dead or alive," "we'll smoke him out of his cave,"
"mission accomplished" and his proud labelling of Iran, Iraq and
North Korea as an "axis of evil."
Apparently, even
Laura Bush doesn't approve of them, although to ears of jingoistic Fox News
viewers such phrases are as milk and honey.
More worrying is
the recent expose by filmmaker Alex Jones, who snuck into the fortress-like
Bohemian Grove, an all-male private club in California, armed with a video
camera.
The resultant
documentary is shocking. Each year the club members whose number include a
succession of US presidents, including the present incumbent, meet to "don
red, black and silver robes before sacrificing an effigy before a giant owl,
otherwise known as "the Great Owl of Bohemia."
This account must
surely represent food-for-thought for parents who regularly tell their erring
offspring to "grow up!"
One of the latest
tit-for-tats spats is between members of the Bush team and Venezuela's Hugo
Chavez, who together with Cuba's Castro and Bolivia's Evo Morales, make up what
Chavez unoriginally calls the "axis of good."
Old Europe
The US defence
secretary, Donald Rumsfeld, who stuck his foot in his mouth terming France and
Germany "old Europe," recently likened Chavez to Hitler. Not to be
outdone Chavez denounces Bush as "Mr Danger," "a killer"
and "a madman."
Across the
Atlantic, British politicians tend to be more circumspect with their
adjectives, with the exception of London's mayor, Ken Livingstone. He was
upbraided for comparing a Jewish reporter to a "Nazi concentration camp
guard" before turning his ire onto the US ambassador to Britain, whom he
called "a chiseling little crook" for trying to avoid London's entry
toll.
Cross the channel
into Europe and it's a different story. France's Interior Minister Nicholas
Sarkozy got himself in hot water for calling young people who live in poor
suburbs "rabble."
Insult watchers
must have been gratified to observe the run-up to the Italian elections where
candidates engaged in mutual vilification with words like "fascist,"
"Mafioso" and "communist" liberally sprinkled around.
Then this week the
Iranian leader Mahmoud Ahmadinejad decided to turn up the international heat on
Tehran with flowery threats against Israel; the country that the US president
recently swore to defend at all costs.
As most of my
regular readers are no doubt aware, I am vehemently opposed to sanctions (or
worse) being imposed on Iran due to its uranium enrichment, which I believe it
has a right to conduct for peaceful purposes.
But every time
Ahmadinejad speaks in this vein, he offers grist to the mill of his enemies,
who claim that the Iranian regime is a dangerous one, even though neither it
nor its predecessors have ever initiated conflict. In this way Iran unfairly
gets the name without the game.
Keen to get in on
the act is the Israeli politician Shimon Peres, who responded to the Iranian
leader's rhetoric with a warning that he would end up like Saddam Hussain.
In the personal
name-calling stakes, Israeli politicians head the list. As the Independent's
Middle East reporter Robert Fisk reminded us, former Israeli prime minister
Menachem Begin referred to Palestinians as "two-legged beasts," Ehud
Barak called them "crocodiles," while former Israeli Chief of Staff
Rafael Eytan said they were like "cockroaches in a glass jar."
We all know that
the pen is mightier than the sword but so are the words that trip off the
tongues of people with their fingers on the button or responsible for the well
being of people who voted for them.
Neo-machismo
All this
neo-machismo prevents dialogue between nations, and it is real dialogue that is
needed now more than ever. How can you proffer olive branches to people who
have called you "evil" or a "terrorist"?
The true grown ups
on the global block are Chinese leaders, who keep their feelings close to their
chests. With the Chinese economy surging through the roof, the Chinese bear
loves to give the impression it's nothing but a panda. Perhaps China would do
well to open a school for foreign politicians with lesson one on the subject of
discretion being the better part of valour.
In an ideal world,
our leaders should stand as role models for young people. We want to respect
our elected officials. We want to believe they are truthful, wise, uncorrupt
and honourable. We want to believe they are doing all they can to keep us safe
rather than pouring verbal fuel on the embers of hatred. A little Chinese
inscrutability could work wonders for their reputations and, who knows, once
the war of words is set aside, they might actually begin to talk.
Linda
S. Heard is a British specialist writer on Middle East affairs. She welcomes
feedback and can be contacted by email at heardonthegrapevines@yahoo.co.uk.