After writing An America I
remember, a mini-memoir of the US in WWII, I thought it only fair to explore
the flipside: the seven-year old, secret program of intelligence agencies to
reclassify and remove documents at the National Archives, a kind of
lobotomizing of America’s political memory.
According to his
Feb. 20 New York Times article, U.S.
Reclassifies Many Documents in Secret Review, Scot Shane says, “ . . . intelligence
agencies have been removing thousands of historical documents that were available
for years, some already published by the State Department and others
photocopied years ago by private historians.” He goes on to say . . .
The restoration of classified status to more than 55,000
previously declassified pages began in 1999, when the Central Intelligence
Agency and five other agencies objected to what they saw as a hasty release of
sensitive information after a 1995 declassification order signed by President
Bill Clinton. It accelerated after the Bush administration took office and especially
after the 2001 terrorist attacks, according to archives records.
But because the reclassification program is itself
shrouded in secrecy -- governed by a still-classified memorandum that prohibits
the National Archives even from saying which agencies are involved -- it
continued virtually without outside notice until December. That was when an
intelligence historian, Matthew M. Aid, noticed that dozens of documents he had
copied years ago had been withdrawn from the archives' open shelves.
Ironically, Aid was struck by the “innocuous contents of the
documents,” dating back to old State Department reports from early cold war and
Korean War days. Apparently, one man’s “innocuous” is another man’s poison.
Shane followed this article with another in the March 3 New York Times, Archivist Urges
U.S. to Reopen Classified File. Shane reported Allen Weinstein, the
US’s chief archivist, announced a “moratorium” on the cutting, i.e.,
reclassification of documents until an audit could be done to find out which
records should be secret and which should not. Good for Weinstein.
When a nation begins to lobotomize part of its historic
memory, we create ignorance, stupefaction, a kind of living Alzheimer’s, and
that’s not good.
My late father, a staunch Republican, suffered from the big
A later in life, from holes in the memory that got larger and larger, until his
brain forgot to tell his body to go on living. One of the few things that
brought him solace as he languished in his nursing home room was a large framed
picture of Ronald Reagan that I brought from his past home. It seemed
appropriate that he could ruminate with his smiling hero as they suffered a mutual
affliction. But, America doesn’t need that kind of heartache to visit its brain
and body politic, on either coast, or anywhere between. Trust me.
Meanwhile, credit should be given to Clinton for signing
that 1995 bill that declassified those 55,000 pages, allowing a mentally
blocked government to be somewhat more candid.
Maybe Clinton’s right action gave Dick Cheney the misguided
idea to tell Scooter Libby to disclose “highly sensitive prewar information to
reporters.” The information, reported by Robert
Wilkinson at Political Physics,
“about Iraq and alleged weapons of mass destruction
was used by the Bush administration to bolster its case for invading
Iraq." Wilkinson continues . . .
Of course, this avoids the reality that this information
should not include the name of a covert agent, as that's a crime no matter
which way Cheney tries to spin it. So it seems that Dubya and Cheney are
claiming the privilege to "declassify" any information they choose,
regardless of whether it violates the law or not.
Cheney also had the chutzpah to say, "I have certainly
advocated declassification. I have participated in declassification
decisions." Asked for details, he said, "I don't want to get into
that. There's an executive order that specifies who has classification
authority, and obviously it focuses first and foremost on the president, but
also includes the vice president."
So it’s
a matter of who has classification authority, mainly the president, who, Cheney
claims, extended it to him via an executive order. So if it ends up that Cheney
was involved in decisions to out the identity of CIA operative Valerie Plame in
reprisal for her husband Joseph Wilson outing the yellow-cake uranium from
Niger fraud, it seems to me it's his punishable crime and not just Scooter
Libby’s boo-boo.
Cheney
and Bush are on both sides of the issue here to conveniently fit their agendas
for secrecy when it suits them to keep the public in the dark, and for
declassification when it can be used to hurt an adversary -- double-dealing
from both sides of their collective mouths.
Coincidentally,
have you noticed how Internet stories and links are vanishing lately, not just
archived documents? Like the link to the original WhatReallyHappened website that had an amazing visual/verbal
presentation of what went down and why on 911.
Perhaps
the creators took it down for their own reasons. Perhaps some other force
snatched it, so a little darkness would fall. The why is important. Because all
cases of declassification versus classification, freedom of the Internet versus
censure, are about one thing, destroying memory and its truth. And the price of
truth and liberty, as we know, is eternal vigilance. But are we prepared to
fight for it? Go to the wall legally and every other which way to protect
access to truth?
Knowledge
begins and ends in human memory. And by extension, we as humans have a deeply
encoded spoken and written language, carrying a great range and subtlety of
meaning and experience to record the good and bad lessons of history.
Denied
the right to view and understand the language of history, that faculty is
stilted, lobotomized. We are as stones in the dark, impediments to our own
progress, prey to the thieves of information who come like gravediggers in the
night to steal the past.
This is
not what the Freedom of Information Act, the Constitution or the Bill of Rights
were all about. Though in the past five years, they seem to have been forgotten
as well.
With
corporate media as the anesthetic of inquiry, lulling millions of Americans
into a no-pain stupor, the pointed, well-sharpened scalpels of intelligence go
to work, leaving just enough brain to keep the public shuffling to work and
back and through the steps of ritualized life.
Additionally,
Big Pharma, the booze and dope industries, step in with anti-depressants and
feel-good potions to keep the post-dumbing pain down. This isn’t Democracy and
hardly life, and tellingly long past 1984 and George Orwell, who
predicted it all.
Resistance
is the only prescription to lobotomy in whatever form. And the time to start
was yesterday. The time to continue every tomorrow. And so, good people
everywhere, now is the time to come to the aid of your country. As I once wrote
in an ad campaign for National Library
Week for the National Book Committee, “You’ve got a write to read. Don’t
blow it.”
Jerry
Mazza is a freelance writer residing in New York. Reach him at gvmaz@verizon.net.