Online Journal
Front Page 
 
 Donate
 
 Submissions
 
 Announcements
 
 NewsLinks
 
 Special Reports
 
 News Media
 
 Elections & Voting
 
 Health
 
 Religion
 
 Social Security
 
 Analysis
 
 Commentary
 
 Editors' Blog
 
 Reclaiming America
 
 The Splendid Failure of Occupation
 
 The Lighter Side
 
 Reviews
 
 The Mailbag
 
 Online Journal Stores
 Official Merchandise
 Amazon.com
 
 Links
 
 Join Mailing List
Search

Commentary Last Updated: Nov 11th, 2009 - 00:59:42


Muslims need not be apologetic
By Linda S. Heard
Online Journal Contributing Writer


Nov 11, 2009, 00:19

Email this article
 Printer friendly page

Muslims make up roughly one quarter of the world’s population. Just because one out of almost 1.5 billion ran amok, leaving 13 dead and 23 wounded, does not mean the entire Muslim nation is responsible.

When Sergeant John M. Russell opened fire on his comrades at Camp Liberty in Baghdad last May, killing five, the media did not even mention his religion. Instead, papers reported that the young man, who “had been broken by the army” was suicidal and in debt.

When National Guard soldier Joshua Cartwright shot and killed two Florida deputies in April, he was characterised as “severely disturbed.” No one investigated his spiritual beliefs. The media, likewise, took a soft approach, last year, when Dustin Thorson, an Air Force sergeant, shot his wife and son at Tinker Airbase and, in 1995, when Sergeant William Kreutzer killed one and injured 18 at Fort Bragg. But when an American-born major with the name Nidal Malek Hassan commits a similar crime he is judged in the court of public opinion based on his ethnicity and religion.

Bill O’Reilly of Fair and Balanced on Fox News has already decided that Hassan is either a “Muslim terrorist” or “crazy.” Fox’s Brian Kilmeade has made up his mind too. He asked a guest, “Do you think it is time for the military to have special debriefings of Muslim Army Officers . . . ?” or “anyone enlisted”?

There are 3,572 Muslims in the US military and it seems that Kilmeade wants all of them to fall under suspicion. Never mind that many have served their commander-in chief loyally in Afghanistan and Iraq!

Needless to say, right-wing and Islamophobe bloggers are having a field day over this tragic incident with many posts too racist and disgusting to re-publish in a family publication. But it isn’t only the hate-filled usual suspects who have jumped to knee-jerk conclusions before the true facts have come to light.

When Fox News host Shepherd Smith spoke to Texas Senator Bailey Hutchison about the tragedy, he said, “The name tells us a lot does it not, senator?” “It does, it does, Shepherd,” came the quick-fire response. It’s little wonder that the Obama team does not consider Fox News as a legitimate news organisation! It has a transparent divisive agenda and, in this case, its anchors are delighting in pouring fuel on an already volatile situation.

In reality, 39-year-old Major Hasan fits the psychological profile of someone who is vulnerable to snapping out of control. An unhappy, unmarried loner with a calm outward exterior, he was angry on several accounts. He was apparently subjected to harassment on base. A relative said Hasan was discriminated against as a Muslim committed to his prayers. He did not support the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq and he did not want to be deployed to either theatre. Prior to his rampage, he had attempted to get his upcoming deployment to Iraq cancelled and had unsuccessfully tried to quit the army before his contract was up. Neither his family nor friends or fellow worshippers in a mosque he regularly attended perceived any signs that Major Hasan harboured extremist tendencies. On the contrary, several of his comrades described him as a committed soldier who loved his country.

Major Hasan has instigated a terrible tragedy which is likely to make life more difficult for his fellow Muslim soldiers and may even reignite anti-Muslim sentiment within the US. Now that he has regained consciousness, perhaps he will explain why he did it. In the meantime, responsible media outlets should refrain from unsubstantiated speculation. Currently, there is no suggestion that he belonged to any extremist group or had ties with terrorists, so any terrorist label is premature.

It is, therefore, shameful that Lt. Col. Allen West (Ret), a Republican candidate for Congress, is hysterically warning that “terrorists are infiltrating the military” and brainwashing “our soldiers.” Major Hasan has been a soldier for 15 years and joined up right out of high school against the wishes of his parents. The idea that he had been planning his attack since childhood is as far-fetched as it gets.

Major Hasan may be mentally ill or he may have been out for revenge when he gunned down innocent unsuspecting people. Whatever the motivation, he’s a one-off. Yet, American Muslims are under pressure to condemn the attack, which Christians and Jews are never required to do when one of their co-religionists turn to violence. I don’t recall Irish Catholics having to dissociate themselves from Oklahoma bomber Timothy McVeigh, for instance.

The Muslim Public Affairs Council, The Islamic Society of North America and The Council on American-Islamic Relations have all deplored Major Hasan’s actions and have offered condolences to the bereaved. I’m sure that all decent human beings, irrespective of race, ethnicity or religion, will share their sentiments.

Linda S. Heard is a British specialist writer on Middle East affairs. She welcomes feedback and can be contacted by email at heardonthegrapevines@yahoo.co.uk.

Copyright © 1998-2007 Online Journal
Email Online Journal Editor

Top of Page

Commentary
Latest Headlines
Some U.S. holiday terror?
The Great Depression meets the Great Recession
American jihad in Pakistan
Who’s afraid of Hiroshima? Obama’s nuclear hypocrisy
Let’s get fiscal: More stimulus, more government jobs programs, more debt relief
Globalization unchecked: How alien media are suffocating real culture
America’s leadership deficit
The US needs to be censured for its immoral behavior
The Hague’s the place for trials
For Obama it’s one (term) if by war, two if by peace
In a chilly London November, war and remembrance
Dying to prosecute Hasan
What is Israel’s role in the destabilization of Pakistan?
Aung San Suu Kyi, Omar Khadr and Barack Obama: A dreadful tale of what America has become
Fifteen very bad things Republicans would do if they got their selfish way
China’s yuan, not the dollar, is too cheap
The US government and the assassination of Tupac Shakur
The reactor relapse takes 3 hits to the head
Major Nidal Malik Hasan, jihadist or patsy?
The humble tuna