On September 26, the New
York Times deemed it fit to run an article, headlined “Thousands Hold
Peaceful March at G-20 Summit,” in which propagandist Ian Urbina informed us of
“several thousand demonstrators” converging on downtown Pittsburgh in light of
that city’s hosting of the Group of 20 (G-20) meeting. Urbina called it a “peaceful
and permitted march.”
The demonstrators, he said, were “calling for solutions to a
range of problems that they attributed to the economic policies of the world
leaders.” Later, he told of speakers urging demonstrators to “fight for an
array of social issues they felt had been largely ignored in global economic
policy.”
“They attributed” and “they felt.”
Okay, in a rare case of actual objectivity, Urbina was
careful to clarify that not everyone agrees with the protesters. However, that’s
where the any attempt at journalism ended. If Urbina were capable of even an
iota of independent thought, he’d have found out why demonstrators feel and
attribute what they feel and attribute. But . . . it’s so much easier to just
describe what they looked liked.
Some wore fatigues, some chimed cymbals, one played a French
horn, 400 “self-described anarchists” were clad in black, and dig this: one
very radical group even “held aloft with bamboo poles a giant fabric replica of
a dove.” None of these dissidents, Urbina reminded us, ever got closer than the
steps of the city-county building, blocks from where the G-20 meeting was being
held.
Ain’t dissent neat?
Surely peace and justice will be upon us soon.
When telling his loyal readers about a group called “Students
for Justice in Palestine” and what they
were calling for, propagandist Urbina was extra-cautious to use quotation
marks: “the Israeli occupation.” A practicing journalist might have at least
used a search engine to include some context from United Nations Security
Council Resolution 242 (1967), which refers to the “inadmissibility of the
acquisition of territory by war” and calls for the “withdrawal of Israel armed
forces from territories occupied in the recent conflict.”
Unburdened by such rudimentary journalistic standards,
Urbina goes on to end his report by quoting a 20-year-old student from Duquesne
University, who was somehow “optimistic that it would be hard to ignore
thousands in the street.” As the student explained, “They will listen to a
certain degree. They might not necessarily do anything.”
Take home message: Fuck the New York Times and fuck peaceful and permitted marches that won’t
necessarily do anything.
Mickey Z. is the author of two upcoming books:
“Self Defense for Radicals” (PM Press) and his second novel, “Dear Vito” (The
Drill Press). Until the laws are changed or the power runs out, he can be found
on the Web at www.mickeyz.net.