Let me clearly define socialism and
single-payer health care, since I see and hear these terms misused many times a
day on radio, television, even in newspapers, mostly to mislead and frighten
people.
First, here’s a paragraph-long definition of socialism from Wikipedia from its longer,
17-page article on the history of socialism:
“Socialists mainly share the belief that capitalism unfairly
concentrates power and wealth among a small segment of society that controls capital, creates an unequal
society, does not provide equal opportunities for everyone to maximize their
potentialities in society and does not utilize technology and resources to
their maximum potential in the public interest. Therefore socialists advocate
the creation of a society in which wealth and power are distributed more evenly
based on the amount of work expended in
production, although there is considerable disagreement among socialists
over how and to what extent this could be achieved.”
Okay? So from the get-go, socialism was trying to level the
playing field for the working class and its trade unions. It was born at odds
with wealthy capitalists, management, and unrestrained free trade in the late
19th century. Is this a bad thing? Not if you work for a living and not for all
of us sitting far from the top of the capitalist totem pole.
In 1864, the International Workingmen’s Association was
founded in London. The much maligned Karl Marx was a member of its organizing
committee. Marx, along with Engels, founded the Social Democratic Workers’
Party of Germany, which included trade unions. In fact, socialist ideas have
had a positive influence as they sailed to the United States and helped labor
learn to talk back to capitalists in terms of working conditions, grueling
hours, and most of all, decent wages to feed their families and have a decent
life.
It was in socialist thinking that American labor found its
voice, which in turn led to the creation of decent wages, corporate retirement
and health plans for employees. Those are now being torn to pieces by
“all-American” corporations so they can pay billions in bonuses to management.
These are the same folks who are offshoring millions of American jobs to fatten
their bottom lines for Wall Street, while driving their former employees into
the ground. Of course, these are the same people who will invoke “socialism” as
a national death threat if you should chose to demand single-payer health care.
Know that it’s another dirty trick, red baiting, a corpse of the Cold War
wheeled out to frighten the naïve.
That’s something you should be scared of, not socialism.
What is scary in socialism’s varied history is the face of the totalitarian
prince of darkness, Joseph Stalin. Stalin subverted this noble idea into a tool
for his own absolute, brutal rule over the Russian people. Yet there are
socialist economies in Sweden, Britain, Belgium, and around the world that are
totally benign and not totalitarian. Stalin was to socialism what Hitler was to
Germany, and then some. In fact, socialism is not so much a political idea or
system as it is an economic concept, with the prime purpose to level inequities
between the rich, the middle class, and the poor. It’s that simple.
Moreover, Social Security, our longest lasting and only
universal retirement plan for the working people of America is a socialist-type
idea. And from that grew Medicare and Medicaid to aid the aged and the poor. So
socialism is not the pariah, the unspeakable word, the Cold War bugaboo, pushed
now particularly by the rich, the insurance companies, Big Pharma, Wall Street
bankers, and all those who would see everyday people confused into a misplaced
flag-waving, contrary to our own good.
To wit, socialist economics have been mixed and matched in
capitalist societies, say, to nationalize commodities like oil, coal, water and
natural gas. This is to protect the people from exactly the kind of price gouging
and speculation you see today. Infrastructure, from trains to roads and
bridges, can be nationalized, even in capitalist economies, to make sure they
operate more economically, not for profit, and again, to protect the people’s
assets from waste.
Socialized medicine has been used effectively to keep
for-profit HMOs and their insurance companies out of health care. It works in
England (a monarchy/free market state), in France (which is a capitalist
state), in tiny Cuba (which is a communist state), as well as Sweden (a
socialist state), and many other states of different political hue in the West
and the East. The common purpose in these countries is to use socialism in
sectors of their economy that should not be left to marketplace dangers, but to
government to run efficiently, free of corporate greed. In the process of doing
this, no one is turned into a state automaton, bullied about, or abused. In
socialized medicine, doctors earn a good living and provide top of the line
medical service and hospital care for the people they serve. Take a look at
Michael Moore’s Sicko. It’s a
documentary reporting on socialized medicine.
If you wish to read more about socialism, read the full Wiki
article. It has a complete bibliography, suggesting other books and articles
you can read, going back to its roots. It will help you demystify the word, the
economic system, all that it is and isn’t. It will take away your fear, which
is the most important thing. Also, read two of my articles: The politics
of trashing the single-payer health care system and The enemies
of America’s real health care reform.
The simple, unadorned truth is that for-profit insurance
companies and Big Pharma are spending hundreds of millions of dollars to stop single-payer
universal health care from becoming a reality. They will do or say anything
they have to via their numerous lobbyists, advertising and public relations
agencies. Remember, we already have three single-payer plans in this country:
Medicare, Medicaid, and the Veterans Administration. Medicare is probably the
best example since its recipients paid into Social Security and Medicare
throughout their working lives. Upon retirement, recipients pay additional
monthly fees, if they choose, for Medicare Part B for physician services and
for Part D for prescription drugs.
Medigap programs can be added to pick up whatever charges
Medicare does not. Unfortunately, they are conducted by for-profit insurance
companies. I use one and find it overly costly for the services provided. Avoid
at all costs the Medicare HMOs, which will dictate your doctors, services, and
your life. They should be eliminated if we wanted to really cut Medicare costs.
Beyond that, avoid at all costs the new note of racism I
hear creeping into the health care soap opera. As if Obama wanted to take all
white people’s money away and give it to poor blacks. It’s ugly, insidious and
idiotic. Remember that the white president you had had also started two illegal
wars at a current cost of two trillion dollars and more than 4,000 American
lives. The financial collapse evolved out of that same administration, what
with Treasury Secretary Paulson showing up in Congress with a two-page ransom
note for $700 billion dollars or a promised economic collapse.
Do not give in to fear, ignorance and a merciless
exploitation of America’s health care. Demand a single-payer system. It won’t
break the bank. It will save it from being broken by for-profit companies.
Jerry Mazza is a freelance writer living in New York
City. Reach him at gvmaz@verizon.net. His new book, “State Of
Shock: Poems from 9/11 on” is available at
www.jerrymazza.com, Amazon or Barnesandnoble.com.